6 ms·
I enjoy working with paper. My favorite notebooks are ISO A4 size because they give me a bit more vertical room and still fit well in my backpacks. The issues
by todd8 12y ago
I enjoy working with paper. My favorite notebooks are ISO A4 size because they give me a bit more vertical room and still fit well in my backpacks.
The issues that come up with regard to US Letter size paper seem to be:
1) It's not metric -- yes that's true, but A4 is 210mm x 297mm. These numbers seem completely arbitrary and don't take advantage of the metric system. I wish the US was on the metric system, but it's not so 8.5 in by 11 inches at least has the advantage that it is measured in simple numbers with respect to standard measures in the US.
2) It's easier to store and work with A4 because it is one half of an A3 sheet -- however, US Letter is one half of the US Tabloid/Ledger size. The ANSI (American National Standards Institute) paper sizes in inches are A (8.5 x 11), B (11 x 17), C (17 x 22), D (22 x 34), etc. and share this advantage with the ISO standard.
3) The aspect ratio is is approximately sqrt(2)/2 for all paper in the A series, the B series, and the C series. But why is having but one shape of paper an advantage? Sometimes it's useful to have choices depending on the content to be printed on the paper. Furthermore, the ANSI paper sizes simply have two aspect ratios alternating as one increases paper size.
It is argued that printing posters with corresponding flyers is easier with ISO paper sizes. But this is true with ANSI paper sizes: one would have to jump up two sizes from letter (ANSI A, 8.5 x 11 inches) to ANSI C (17 x 22 inches). So, for the case where one would like to print at ANSI B, the aspect ratio of the page is a bit different. Here we have, what appears to me, to be the first real advantage of ISO over ANSI paper, where we need to print a flyer at A4 and A5 (but not A6). However, this hasn't been a problem for me personally. I'm usually working with pages that have additional constraints. For example space for bindings or differences in margins between recto and verso sides of two sided printing. Whenever there are bindings involved the aspect ratio advantage goes out the window.
4) Every country uses ISO sizes, why not the US (and Canada and Mexico) -- well, this is oversimplifying things a bit. Take a look at the Wikipedia page for paper sizes. There are Japanese variants, German extensions, and Swedish extensions listed that deviate from the ISO standards. There are also Architectural sizes listed that are designed to have simple ratios for their aspect ratios.
The idea that we would somehow be better off with fewer choices (just one) really for aspect ratio really strikes me as wrong. I like all the variety available in paper.
- murbard2 12y ago1) A0 is 1m^2
- rs232 12y agoWhich also lets you caclulate the weight of a document (say for shipping): Standard printer paper is 80g/m2: A1 = 40g, A2 = 20g, A3=10g and A4=5g. Or, alternatively, crumple up A4 sheets for quick 5g weights.
- slowmovintarget 12y agoU.S. Letter size predates the European standard. The U.S. Letter size apparently originates with vellum sizes and was originally intended for handwriting not typography[1]. However, there are some good ways to use 8.5 x 11 [2] that might look odd on narrower and taller paper. [1] http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2012/09/why-8-12-x-11.html http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2012/09/why... [2] http://retinart.net/graphic-design/secret-law-of-page-harmony/ http://retinart.net/graphic-design/secret-law-of-page-harmon...
- mpweiher 12y agoYou write that the A4 numbers "seem completely arbitrary". While they might seem to be arbitrary, they are obviously not the least bit arbitrary. The base size A0 has an area of exactly 1 square meter. Each subsequent size is constructed by taking half of the previous, so for A4 it's 1/16th of a square meter, or 0.0625 sqare meters, 625 square centimeters, which is 21.0 cm x 27.9 cm (approximately). In order to have both the halving property and the self-similarity the aspect ratio has to be sqrt(2), and therefore you can't have nice little round numbers for the sides. If I have to choose between self-similarity and nice round numbers, I'll take self-similarity, thank you.
- azth 12y ago> The base size A0 has an area of exactly 1 square meter. Which is still arbitrary :)
- 12y ago