2 ms·
> but this likely wouldn't be here if CoreOS hadn't shaken things up the way they did with ACI/Rocket. It's not "likely", it's absolute. The so-called Docker
by Alupis 12y ago
> but this likely wouldn't be here if CoreOS hadn't shaken things up the way they did with ACI/Rocket.
It's not "likely", it's absolute.
The so-called Docker "Standard" was cooked up overnight the weekend ACI was released. Prior to ACI's release, Docker made active steps to prevent there being a unified standard... they were petrified that a unified image format standard would allow someone to swoop in and eat their lunch. Docker lived in a world where nobody else would dare make any competing container system.
It seems to have all started with this github issue[1]. Docker employees are initially interested in collaborating with CoreOS and helping to co-develop an open standard -- then Shykes shuts it all down.
They call Docker an implementation of their "Docker Standard", however it's really the other way around -- the "standard" was an afterthought -- and to that end it's unproven, untested and likely incomplete. There are no other implementations of their "standard" -- so the holes have not been found. ACI already has several working implementations, and many more in the oven at this moment. They have contributed immensely back to the open standard and helped evolve it into a community driven specification -- not dictated by any single organization or source.
[1] https://github.com/docker/docker/issues/9538 https://github.com/docker/docker/issues/9538
- steeve 12y agoShykes doesn't "shuts it all down". And to be honest, I think he's got a pretty good point. If anything he encourages for the Docker format to be more documented: > But here's a suggestion for you. If you were to complain that Docker's image format and runtime specification, as massively adopted as it is, is not appropriately documented, and it could be made easier to produce alternate implementations - then I would completely agree with you. In response, I would encourage the project maintainers to improve the specs documentation based on your suggestions. I would also encourage you to join the effort, and offer my help in the process.
- Alupis 12y ago> If anything he encourages for the Docker format to be more documented This was after the Docker project deleted the original spec [1] in September 2013 -- ACI wasn't publically annoucned until December 1st 2014, and then Docker rolled out their "standard" in a hurry on December 7th 2014. https://github.com/docker/docker/commit/eed00a4afd1e8e8e35f8ca640c94d9c9e9babaf7 https://github.com/docker/docker/commit/eed00a4afd1e8e8e35f8...
- ash 12y agoIt was a container manifesto that got deleted in the commit you've mentioned. I don't see any spec there.
- girvo 12y agoThat's not a spec. I've got no side in this, but what you're saying has happened and what actually seems to have happened based on reading your links doesn't match up, in my opinion.