4 ms·
1. Do you think the people who will be using this are actually going to read this marketing copy? (hint: it's not in their language, assuming they are literate)
by peterwwillis 12y ago
1. Do you think the people who will be using this are actually going to read this marketing copy? (hint: it's not in their language, assuming they are literate)
2. Their current systems involve constantly buying and rationing kerosene, candles, and batteries. Do you think 'rechargeability' is their primary concern?
- dredmorbius 12y agoThen ask yourself: 1. Who is this copy aimed at? More likely investors than customers. 2. If you're going to lie and misrepresent the story to your investors, how much respect do you suspect the company will show its actual customers? 3. English is in fact one of the two official languages of the Philippines (http://www.filipinolanguages.com/html/languages.html http://www.filipinolanguages.com/html/languages.html) There's a bit of classic advice which says "don't do business with (or work for) assholes". These guys are assholes.
- peterwwillis 12y agoAssholes, huh? That's funny. Because it almost seems like you've never worked with an NGO to try to convince local villages and governments to adopt a new product that upends their cultural norms with new technology. Because someone who might talk about the problems with attracting funding to the projects, without knowing anything about them, might be seen as an asshole. 1. The copy is primarily a marketing tool; it is not sales copy. For investors they may work with NGOs, local outreach organizations, file for grants, and make requests of a few private companies that work in the region. The website is just boilerplate, and any intelligent person who's attracted by the idea and works in this field is not going to assume someone is a scammer because their copy does not include technical jargon or scientific wordage. 2. They are not lying. You are arguing semantics. The product works as advertised; I challenge you to quote the 'misleading' sections verbatim so we can have a word-off. And seeing how the company is made up of filipinos and working directly with local tribes to bring them the product, I trust them a lot more than a bunch of bay area hipsters with scientifically-accurate marketing copy. I suggest buying a good mirror.
- ta75757 12y agoWhile I would not have used the harsh words, grandparent is right in most respects. I challenge you to quote the 'misleading' sections verbatim Voila: Sustainable and cost effective ecologically designed lamp powered by "tap water" and "table salt!" The lamp is not powered by tap water or table salt. It is powered by a non-rechargeable battery. This is misleading, putting it charitably. To anyone who knows anything about energy, this is not just "semantics" it is an false claim about the fundamental nature of the product. Perhaps they meant to put "powered" in scare quotes, not "tap water" and "table salt" but they didn't. Edit: more examples You can also use the ocean-water to power up your lamp! Use the ocean-water to power up your lamp and it will give you 8 hours of running-time. Store ocean-water in bottles and use them to power up you lamp anytime, anywhere. To a naive reader these statements imply that the energy comes from the ocean water. It does not, therefore the statements are misleading.
- peterwwillis 12y agoThere are no false claims in this web site. The entire product is explained - just not in one sentence. They explain that salt + water added to the lamp will create power, which it will, because that's the only thing the machine lacks in order to produce power. They also explain that an anode has to be replaced every six months. According to the theory of similar devices, this is all that is involved with the creation of the power, thus, this is the entire design and function of the product. --- If you have a car, and I said "this car is powered by gasoline", would this be a misleading, false claim about the product? Would I be a liar? According to you and the parent commenter, Yes, because the car requires a battery and spark plugs to ignite the gasoline along with oxygen. Technically speaking, gasoline, oxygen, vacuum, a battery, spark plugs, a fuel pump, fuel injectors, an ECU, sensors, pistons, valves, and a whole lot more shit are needed to "power" the car. Without all those things there is no "power" created. What generates the power directly is spark igniting a precise mixture of gas and oxygen, which then applies force to mechanical parts. But a lot more things are involved in making that happen, and maintenance is required on most of it. All of which the average car user has no effing clue about. You do not need to know any of that in order to 'power' a car. And I am not a liar for telling you a car is 'powered' by gasoline. I simply didn't explain the design of the internal combustion engine to you. The car comes with a battery, spark plugs and oxygen, just like this lamp comes with an anode, and it needs regular maintenance, just like the various parts of a car. Just like gasoline for a car, water and salt are the fuel for this lamp. The fuel is the only part you need to understand to use it. They explain several times that the anode has to be replaced every six months [based on average use]. They have omitted nothing. There is no deception. Just simple language explaining only what you need to know to use it. > To anyone who knows anything about energy, this is not just "semantics" it is an false claim about the fundamental nature of the product The product's users are not chemists or engineers. They're tribal villagers in the Philippines, for christ's sake. Anyone who speaks english and is intelligent enough to pay for the project will read the whole thing, just like all of us did, and realize how it works, just like all of us did, and be satisfied.