3 ms·
Repealing the DMCA would also work. Completely overhauling the copyright system from the ground up would be even better. I know that when you're the little gu
by logfromblammo 12y ago
Repealing the DMCA would also work. Completely overhauling the copyright system from the ground up would be even better.
I know that when you're the little guy, you have to pick your battles wisely, but there are a lot of things we can no longer do as a society because our public domain is no longer growing.
Making an exemption to the DMCA is a temporary fix. For software, we should probably have a completely separate system of granted monopoly, wherein the protections are contingent upon deposit of the source code with the patent and trademark office, which would then become public record when the protection expires (on a completely independent time scale from anything to do with Mickey Mouse).
- rtpg 12y agobut isn't the DMCA what provides for safe harbor provisions?
- wtallis 12y agoEven the good bits of the DMCA are deeply flawed. The safe harbor section includes the shoot first, ask questions later takedown procedure with unequal standards for claimants and defendants. Title 3 of the DMCA addressed the issue of unauthorized copying due to loading a program from disk into RAM by explicitly authorizing computer repair technicians to run your OS and other necessary software even without having their own license. Left unaddressed is the more general reality of how bits are almost never actually moved, merely copied. The anti-circumvention section provides for exemptions, but they only last three years so they're pretty much impossible for a serious business to rely on.
- rayiner 12y ago> but there are a lot of things we can no longer do as a society because our public domain is no longer growing. Serious question: what useful advance is being held back by a bunch of abandoned entertainment not going into the public domain?
- tptacek 12y agoCalvin and Hobbes action figures and the Disney XD Calvin and Hobbes cartoon.
- nitrogen 12y agoThe question is unanswerable because we don't have access to a parallel universe with sane copyrights. We can't predict that future, or even a parallel present. I can think of a number of artistic references that would be culturally interesting ways to incorporate old video game code into new games, but there's no way to predict what will be created after several cultural iterations across a few generations. We can only imagine the art of which we are being deprived.