4 ms·
What does it mean for the crystals of the 'inner inner core' to be aligned in an 'east-west direction'? Its a sphere. Does that mean they are aligned in a ring,
by JoeAltmaier 12y ago
What does it mean for the crystals of the 'inner inner core' to be aligned in an 'east-west direction'? Its a sphere. Does that mean they are aligned in a ring, like the grooves in an lp (or the dots on a CD/DVD)? Why doesn't the graphic reflect that?
- jofer 12y agoThey mean that there's a preferred lineation to the individual grains. Consider cutting a sphere out of something similar to this: http://minerva.union.edu/hollochk/c_physicalgeology/images/Lineation1.jpg http://minerva.union.edu/hollochk/c_physicalgeology/images/L... You can imagine making a sphere by packing together a bunch of small needles. Not all of them need to be oriented the same way, but they can align under the right conditions. Because the needles are small in comparison to the size of the sphere, that alignment can change depending on where you are in the sphere. In this case, they're hypothesizing that the "needles" are basically oriented differently at the outside of the sphere than near the center. More specifically, that they're oriented north-south at the outside of Earth's inner core and "east-west" near the center of Earth's inner core. This is based on the observation that there's a strong anisotropy to the seismic velocities in the innermost parts of the Earth's core. The easiest way to explain any sort of seismic anisotropy this is through alignment of mineral grains (In many minerals sound travels faster along one axis of the crystal structure than along the other). However, this is one of the first times anyone's been able to clearly resolve differences in aniostropy with depth into the inner core.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoStill not registering. There's no 'east pole' like there is a north pole. I get it, that the grains are in the plane of latitude instead of longitude. That still doesn't say which way they are aligned in that plane - randomly? Circularly? Radially?
- jofer 12y agoSorry, I should have been more clear. They have to be aligned linearly parallel to a line going from Central America to Southeast Asia. If they were aligned any other way, you wouldn't have a fast axis in any particular direction.
- tjradcliffe 12y agoThe question is, if you cut the Earth through the equatorial plane and looked down at the exposed core, would the "east-west" grains follow circles around the plane, or would they form lines pointing across the plane?
- jofer 12y agoLines pointing across the plane. Otherwise there wouldn't be a fast axis.
- ChuckMcM 12y agoIron crystallizes at high pressure, while the iron is molten it aligns itself with any magnetic field, then as it crystallizes it can no longer change direction as the field changes. This paper suggests that as the inner part of the core was solidifying, the earth had east/west magnetic poles rather than north/south magnetic poles. And then something "big" happened to switch the poles north/south. That "big" thing happened in a fairly short period of time (geologically) if the boundry between east/west alignment and north/south alignment in the crystals is thin. They also mention the core is solidifying at a rate of .5mm per year. Which is how they hope to "date" the event that occurred. Although it is unclear to me if they consider the process to be dependent on the surface volume or not. Does that help?
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoNot a bit. There's no such thing as an east pole or west pole, like there is a north pole.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- bdamm 12y agoI think the implication is that magnetic North was on the equator, rather than at the geologic pole.
- ChuckMcM 12y agoexactly this. If you had a compass and were on the planet while those crystals were forming, the 'north' part of the compass would point you to a point along the equator rather than in the upper latitudes as it does now.
- uxp 12y agoFrom what I understand, they mean that the "east" and "west" poles were, at that time, north and south. The something big flipped the earth so the solidified iron was east west, and then the rest of the core started solidifying to it's current north/south direction. They aren't calling it a east/west pole, but that the north/south of that magnetic sphere are unnaturally aligned as so they are east/west relative to what we understand as north/south.
- jessaustin 12y agoThe crystals are oriented due to the presence of a magnetic field. The different orientation indicates that the magnetic field has changed, but it's difficult to imagine a possible magnetic field inside an iron mass that wouldn't be essentially polar, unlike the ring alignment you describe. We know that the magnetic poles move around relative to the crust, and we know they occasionally flip. It's not inconceivable that at one time there was a large movement of the poles relative to the crust.