3 ms·
Lots of hate here. How about: this drone may be safer than an ambulance, careening through intersections and hurtling down local roads? Its not just a neat ide
by JoeAltmaier 12y ago
Lots of hate here. How about: this drone may be safer than an ambulance, careening through intersections and hurtling down local roads?
Its not just a neat idea; its inevitable that quadcopters take a bigger role in the future.
- drzaiusapelord 12y agoI think there's always a level of technological pessimism with people. When I was a kid it was with computers. "This stupid thing? All its good for is holding recipes and I can get a recipe book that doesn't cost $3000!" Or when I was a teen, the pessimism of Mars missions was popular. I think there were 3 or 4 Mars movies all of which ended in disaster. Now its a boring budget line item at NASA. The pessimists have been in high-gear lately about anything that removes human judgement from the equation. High profile anti-AI and anti-drone screeds are here to stay. I just think people buy into neo-ludditism very easily and lash out at automation because it says that humans aren't as important to the process as we thought we were. Ned Ludd vs progress is a story we have yet to learn from and are destined to repeat, probably endlessly, as automation and AI make more sense than human judgement and human risk in so many cases. Our grandkids will be laughing at antiquated ideas like an error-prone human driver the same way we laugh at, say, riding a horse to work or hand-making things that are easily mass producible.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoI don't think this is the kind of pessimism you see here. What people are basically saying is that this concept looks cool in the picture, but is crap from engineering point of view. No one is saying we don't need better tech for rescue operations.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoNot quite? The hate was mostly 'why not a helicoptor' which shows a profound misunderstanding of the mechanics of a quadrotor.
- mariusz79 12y agoA lot of hate towards this tech here is only based on one fact - it's not built with Javascript (yet)
- JshWright 12y agoMaybe someday... There is a lot of technology that needs to be developed between here and there... Current battery tech isn't even close to being able to manage this. There are also a significant number of challenges that won't be easily solved with technology... In my experience, a significant number of emergency scenes do not have a readily accessible landing site within easy walking distance, and there are a lot of weather conditions that wouldn't trouble a ground based ambulance, but would ground this thing.
- evgen 12y agoIf you want a fun time take a look at projected "technology of the future" from the 1910s or 1950s. The former was lots of steam-powered versions of things that already existed and the latter was nuclear versions of the same. Now we are seeing the quadcopter/drone version of this particular delusion. As others have pointed out, a quadcopter is ill-suited to this task, will probably not have the lift-capacity or range to make this work effectively, is not as safe as the helicopter version. While quadcopter drones may play a bigger role in the future it may also turn out that the sweet-spot for these devices is in moving small objects short distances, where they are already being used -- we might just be at a point where we can see the limit of what quadcopters can actually accomplish given battery tech available for the next twenty years or so. Here is another idea to consider: scale down a real helicopter or a tiltrotor to handle a patient and attending nurse and attach drone controls to that.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoExcept it doesn't mean anything to say 'attach drone controls' to a helicopter. A quadcoptor has different physical performance characteristics that dictate the form of its controls. A helicopter will never behave similarly. Quadcopters have wonderful physical properties that make them suitable for maneuvering in tight spaces, far beyond a helicopter.
- evgen 12y agoThe problem is that those same wonderful properties make them completely unsuitable for the task at hand. They have a weight threshold that severely limits their uses and they are unsafe for carrying anything important that cannot take a drop from max height at max velocity given the failure modes. Making better/smarter autopilots for a small helicopter or VTOL aircraft that can actually fly point to point would be more useful and might actually work, unlike this quadcopter idea.