3 ms·
I think the idea that investment in a child's education is more to the benefit of the general society than the benefit of the parent is a good point, but the au
by wodenokoto 12y ago
I think the idea that investment in a child's education is more to the benefit of the general society than the benefit of the parent is a good point, but the author obstructs himself by saying that the state claims the child's future earnings.
The state doesn't make particular claim to the child's future earning. It makes equal claims to the parent's earning.
So either, this argumentation goes down a path about taxes vs. no-taxes, which should be irrelevant to the overall topic or the argument should stick with the claim that a productive members is useful to society in a broad sense, but doesn't directly pay back the cost of raising it to its parents and just leave it at that.
- cpursley 12y ago> The state doesn't make particular claim to the child's future earning. Not true in the United States at least. Children born as Americans are taxed based on citizenship regardless of where they live and work.
- TheCoelacanth 12y agoOnly for the small number of people who don't pay taxes to the country where they live.
- wodenokoto 12y agoMy point is, it is the same for the parent.