3 ms·
vs 747 vv A380 http://www.articlesextra.com/main-fotos/antonov-graph.jpg http://www.articlesextra.com/main-fotos/antonov-graph.jpg More stats: http://planes.
by peteretep 12y ago
vs 747 vv A380
http://www.articlesextra.com/main-fotos/antonov-graph.jpg http://www.articlesextra.com/main-fotos/antonov-graph.jpg
More stats:
http://planes.findthebest.com/compare/242-247/Airbus-A380-800-vs-Antonov-AN-225-Mriya http://planes.findthebest.com/compare/242-247/Airbus-A380-80...
My take-away: A380 significantly more impressive plane. It has a max take-off weight that's 90% of the AN-225, but is a similar size, and much much cheaper to fly, with a significantly better range.
- TylerE 12y agoThst's rather a pointless comparison - the AN-225 is a MUCH more capable aircraft. http://www.aviationexplorer.com/Antonov_An-225/an-225.jpg http://www.aviationexplorer.com/Antonov_An-225/an-225.jpg When dealing with air cargo dimensions are more important usually than weight. The -225 routinely carries things like railway cars and wind turbine blades. No way you could even think of loading those on a hypothetical A380 cargo version - you need to engineer from the outset for a pivoting nose and/or full size rear ramp. The -225 has both.
- peteretep 12y ago> Thst's rather a pointless comparison - the AN-225 is a > MUCH more capable aircraft. > http://www.aviationexplorer.com/Antonov_An-225/an-225.jpg They stuck the shuttle on a 747, and there's no particular reason to think it couldn't go on an A380. > When dealing with air cargo dimensions are more > important usually than weight Weight and fuel efficiency are by far the most important air-cargo considerations, absolutely dwarfing _every_ _single_ other concern. Awkward loads are a miniscule edge case, which is why there was precisely 1 AN-225 built, 5 Belugas, and 4 Dreamlifters, as compared to the mind-boggling amount of air freighters, and passenger aircraft carrying freight. > you need to engineer from the outset for a pivoting nose > and/or full size rear ramp The Beluga and Dreamlifter both are modified version of existing non-pivoting-nose airframes, and there's even a 747-400 (747-400F) modification where the front lifts up.
- zaroth 12y agoI really appreciate the detailed rebuttal over the more characteristic downvote!
- hueving 12y agoI appreciate the metadata comment about something that I assume used to exist. But you should probably delete it now because it no longer makes sense.
- zaroth 12y agoI did! In fact, I think I must have done it concurrently to you posting this reply, as I never saw your post when going back to edit my own :-)
- eigenvector 12y agoI'd be interested to know where those wind turbine blades went that it was cheaper to bring them in this way vs. building a road, and the project still made sense with insane transportation costs. A modern 50m class blade costs no more than $500,000, frequently less than $200,000.
- TylerE 12y agoDon't think about the last mile problem....think about getting them from the factory thousands of miles away.
- smackfu 12y agoThe one example I can find was two 42m blades from China to Denmark in 2010. I would think they normally go by ship, so maybe they were in a rush? And if they were shorter, they would use a smaller plane.
- Shivetya 12y agobetween this beauty and the Soviet ground effect aircraft I have always been more impressed with what the Soviets did build than many of the items we only dreamed about. Outside of the spruce goose its like we handed over the reins of building the behemoths that graced fiction magazinesto them
- arjn 12y agoThe An-225 first flew in 1988 while the first A380 in 2005. It's reasonable to assume the A380 benefited signifcantly from material advances the An-225 didn't have.
- peteretep 12y agoSure, and the Hughes H-4 Hercules, which had a wider wingspan, although it was a bit shorter, first (and only ever) flew in 1947, and was MADE OUT OF WOOD. It's reasonable to assume the AN-225 benefited significantly from material advances (like not being made of wood) that the H-4 Hercules didn't have.
- arjn 12y agoI'm not sure what your point is ? Did anyone make a comparison between the H-4 and the An-225 ? I was only referring to your poorly thought out A380 vs An-225 statment.
- iamcreasy 12y agoYour first link doesn't work. "Error : You don't have permission to access /main-fotos/antonov-graph.jpg on this server." If A380 is cheaper, why Airbus don't product a freight version of A380? Perhaps a comparison with Airbus Beluga/Boeing Dreamlifter with An-225 would be more interesting.
- peteretep 12y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airbus_A380#A380F http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airbus_A380#A380F
- unwind 12y agoThat article clearly says: However, production has been suspended until the A380 production lines have settled with no firm availability date. So it seems that there is no freight version of the A380 for the time being.
- peteretep 12y ago> That article clearly says Which is why I linked to it, because the parent post asked: >> If A380 is cheaper, why Airbus don't product a freight >> version of A380?
- greglindahl 12y agoThe new Boeing 747-8 freighter sold well enough that Airbus was unable to get sufficient orders to launch the A380 freighter variant. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_747-8 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_747-8
- sandworm 12y agoBut does the A380 carry it's own tow bar? Or have a massive cargo nose? Or have a floor that can handle heavy cargo pallets? Can it kneel? How many spare parts fly with the plane? Total apples and oranges. The AN-225 is built like a tank whereas the A380 and 747 are more like coke cans. Not joking. I bet they have mass/volume ratios comparable to aluminum cans.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]