3 ms·
Nonsense. Net neutrality doesn't factor in at all. Bad infrastructure problems are not solved by net neutrality. Net neutrality regulation prohibits telcos from
by thirsteh 12y ago
Nonsense. Net neutrality doesn't factor in at all. Bad infrastructure problems are not solved by net neutrality. Net neutrality regulation prohibits telcos from actively throttling certain types of content, traffic to certain sites, etc. It does not require that telcos provide fast connections in general, or that they keep their infrastructure in good condition. It does not require that telcos provide X amount of bandwidth for X amount of dollars per month. Google Fiber is as relevant as it has always been.
It's sad that this is even remotely controversial. Why can't pundits look at countries like Sweden, Japan, South Korea, Estonia, Germany, ...the list goes on, and see that regulation and competition can go hand in hand?
All that these net neutrality changes will do is prevent existing ISPs from becoming (read: becoming -- most ISPs don't do anything that violates net neutrality right now!) even shittier. It changes almost nothing when it comes to competition. The U.S. is still hilariously out-of-date compared with the rest of the (more-strictly-regulated) industrialized world, and consumers will continue to demand better whether or not there's regulation in place to prevent bottom-of-the-barrel behavior.
- wtallis 12y agoGoogle Fiber is a huge improvement over DSL and Cable, but it doesn't have to be. That's just a side effect of it being a new network built with current technology instead of 90s technology. If Google were instead rolling out DOCSIS at significantly lower prices than the incumbents, it would still get the job done. The incumbent ISPs have a clear track record of moving in a direction that's dangerous to Google: they react badly to new technology (Bittorrent throttling/blocking), they acquire new conflicts of interest (Comcast+NBC, DSL providers introducing TV), they do what they can to cause trouble for Netflix, and they lobby and sue against even the regulations that shouldn't pose any trouble. In the meantime, the regulations Google needs to protect its core business haven't made any tangible progress until this year.