6 ms·
Huh. I thought the answer was obvious, so I'm wrong. My explanation: private monopolies are subject to being broken apart by the government. Government-regulat
by dsr_ 12y ago
Huh. I thought the answer was obvious, so I'm wrong.
My explanation: private monopolies are subject to being broken apart by the government. Government-regulated monopolies are not. Title II regulation means that Comcast and ATT-Time-Warner-AOL-Prodigy-Verizon will survive forever, and be profitable forever. Insanely profitable like a start-up? No, that's no longer possible, but it wasn't before, either.
- AnthonyMouse 12y agoPretty much, yes. The telecoms protestations to Title II have very much the ring of "please Brer Fox, don't throw me into the briar patch." What they want most of all is to be totally unregulated and have no competition. But that isn't long-term stable. That's how you get everyone to hate you with such a passion that it causes everyone to get together and do something about it, and they have to know that. But if Title II and network neutrality will keep the public's rage at a simmer rather than a rolling boil then it means they don't have to worry about a stronger backlash like widespread construction of municipal fiber.
- thirsteh 12y agoWhat, why? Google Fiber, municipal fiber, etc. will continue to exist and grow regardless of how broadband is classified. Title II doesn't mean "no competition."
- AnthonyMouse 12y agoThink what it does to Google's incentive to expand Google Fiber if the law prohibits Verizon et al from doing the things Google is most afraid of them doing. Imagine how much harder it would be to get voter support for a bond issue to fund municipal fiber if the incumbent ISP can't (and there for didn't) degrade performance of popular websites to favor their own competing alternatives. People fix things that are broken. If network neutrality makes Verizon's network tolerable to everyone then support for expensive alternatives disappears.
- sbov 12y agoGoogle has at least claimed net neutrality won't have any affect on their current or future plans for fiber rollout. Also, I think their incentives go beyond the throttling net neutrality is meant to prevent. Google makes more money the faster our connections are.
- AnthonyMouse 12y ago> Google has at least claimed net neutrality won't have any affect on their current or future plans for fiber rollout. We can distinguish between Google (the search engine) and Google Fiber (the ISP). What Google Fiber is saying is that network neutrality won't make their ISP business less profitable. That doesn't mean Google's search business is going to have the same incentive to continue providing a de facto subsidy for it in the form of new capital.
- zaroth 12y agoBut I think the point of Google Fiber is not to be an expensive alternative. Fiber-to-the-home is inevitable, it's just a question of how many decades it takes to get there. Once the fiber is run, it's done. From everything I've read it makes zero economic sense to do anything but. The interesting variable is the CPE. I don't understand the desire to keep it on the pole where it needs to be protected from the elements. The life-cycle of the CPE is also an order of magnitude shorter than the life-cycle of the fiber. The hit to get the physical fiber into the home seems like a rounding error compared to being able to simply build a fiber connector into the router and let the customer pay for upgrading their hardware every X years.
- thirsteh 12y agoSorry, but that sounds to me like anti-regulation/anti-government mumbo-jumbo. You're insinuating Google won't be able to compete because it's going to be illegal for carriers to actively become worse than they already are, while neglecting just that: They're bad! They're slow. They have bad peering agreements. Their networks are congested. None of these issues are solved by net neutrality regulation, and they're all reasons why people want Google Fiber or municipal broadband. Net neutrality barely factors in at all.
- rhino369 12y agoThey do have some competition. Cable co. v. Telecom. Nothing in these new regulations will do anything to increase it. In fact, it probably decreased the chances of increased competition. There is a meme on the internet that ISPs are insanely profitable. But even a cursory look at the facts shows differently. There is a reason why Verizon is selling off as much of its wireline network as it can. Why would they do that? If it is a monopoly that lays a golden egg? And they aren't even talking the money they are getting for their spin offs and reinvesting in their network. They are giving it back to shareholders. Clearly Verizon doesn't think wireline is profitable. Cable companies have a major competitive advantage. They don't have to build a fiber network. Coax will bring us well passed 1Gbps. All that is needed is their equipment upgrades. But even cable is facing an existential crisis. Cord cutting will destroy their business model.
- AnthonyMouse 12y ago> There is a meme on the internet that ISPs are insanely profitable. That's because they are, in fact, insanely profitable. > There is a reason why Verizon is selling off as much of its wireline network as it can. Why would they do that? If it is a monopoly that lays a golden egg? That's easy. Because it allows them to convert 50 years worth of future profits into an immediate payday. Which is only possible because their wireline network is worth billions of dollars, otherwise nobody would be willing to pay them that much for it. > But even cable is facing an existential crisis. Cord cutting will destroy their business model. Their business model is defective. The vast majority of their costs come from providing fast data service. The marginal cost of providing TV service on top of that is a small fraction of that. Which means they're significantly undercharging for internet service and overcharging for TV and phone service. Customers should be paying exactly the same for "triple play" packages as they do now but the "internet only" package should be most of that price because it constitutes most of the cost. At that point they can stop caring if you drop the TV package in favor of Netflix because they don't need it to be profitable -- and with any luck they'll eventually just stop offering it, because it makes no more sense for a physical infrastructure business to be offering TV streaming than for them to offer search or social networking. It just isn't their primary business anymore.
- kokey 12y agoThe regulation also doesn't do price fixing. It sets additional standards, or what I refer to as 'quality fixing'. The effect is that prices go up and competition go down, but quality will at least be something people will complain about less.
- Shivetya 12y agowell that and they can pretty much suspend build out for years while raking in the bucks. eventually they might have to put more cable down but likely will get subsidies to do so