4 ms·
A critique of the Atlantic Magazine article, Does the Vaccine Matter?
- ghshephard 17y ago". On the other hand, the nostrums also touted in this article as a substitute for vaccines and antivirals, like washing your hands, have almost no scientific support in the literature for influenza." Really? Someone should give the NIH the heads up: http://www.flu.gov/individualfamily/prevention/index.html http://www.flu.gov/individualfamily/prevention/index.html Flu Home > For Individuals & Families > Prevention & Treatment "Take these everyday steps to protect your health: ... Wash your hands often with soap and water, especially after you cough or sneeze. Alcohol-based hand cleaners are also effective."
- ikitat 17y agoBased on the context of the article I believe the hand washing comment was made tongue-in-cheek.
- camccann 17y agoInfluenza spreads by some combination of airborne particles containing viruses (e.g., from infected people sneezing) and surface contamination. The relative importance of each is unknown, and there's actually not much in the way of research indicating that hand washing helps appreciably (it's rather difficult to measure). That said, it can't really hurt, either, and may help avoid opportunistic infections joining the fray in someone who does get the flu. So it's not surprising that organizations advising the general public would tell people to wash their hands, evidence or no.
- marze 17y agoTo me, the biggest point made in the Atlantic article was that the flu vaccines have not been double blind tested, which seems incredible. However, this critique doesn't seem to argue with that point, unless I'm misreading it.
- ikitat 17y agoAs I understand it Jackson disregards any data that wasn't gathered via a randomized, double-blinded, placebo controlled trial (RCT). Performing a trial with a placebo for flu vaccines has ethical implications because the flu vaccine has been proven effective. Possibly causing harm by not preventing the flu in subjects. Another point in the critique is that Jackson's findings are based on seasonal flu and not pandemic flu. His findings are for people 60 and older, an age group not particularly targeted by the H1N1 flu.
- billswift 17y agoRobin has a post about this controversy at Overcoming Bias http://www.overcomingbias.com/2009/10/flu-shot-doubts.html http://www.overcomingbias.com/2009/10/flu-shot-doubts.html . "revere" cost himself a bit of credibility with me by working his leftist/progressive politics into the article and especially his comment replies.