2 ms·
In Sweden, there was a famous case in which this premise was tested. A cable channel gave out a public accessible web link to customers after payment, which the
by belorn 12y ago
In Sweden, there was a famous case in which this premise was tested. A cable channel gave out a public accessible web link to customers after payment, which then got naturally shared. The cable channel sued the person who shared the link, arguing that it was copyright infringement since it allowed unauthorized users to access the site (case called Canal Plus-fallet). The defense argued that since there was no restriction added to the site, that that meant it was public.
The court went with the side of the cable company, even if many commentates disagree. What effect a Swedish case can have on German law depend, but using European court case as guides is quite common in Swedish courts if there is no other prior cases. Same might apply for German courts.
- allendoerfer 12y agoThat is unfortunate. I think from a technical point of view, my interpretation of the "laws of the web" are true. What courts decide is an other story. It is part of the bigger problem, that courts do not understand every aspect of our complex society and have to listen to experts, which just defers to problem to the election of these experts. You do not want to give them the power either, because they are easier to lobby than justices. I just hope, that a generation of justices and politician arises, that understands basic principles the web is built on. Like links, that give the web its name, and how they work, who can control them and so on.
- dredmorbius 12y agoThe US Supreme Court has also cited EU court cases.