7 ms·
> I can only speak for myself. I find docker to be immensely useful It seems you are making an argument not for Docker itself, but for containers in Linux in g
by Alupis 12y ago
> I can only speak for myself. I find docker to be immensely useful
It seems you are making an argument not for Docker itself, but for containers in Linux in general. To that point, something like the App Container Specification standard and one of it's implementations would suit your needs just as well, if not better. There are already 3 prominent implementations of App Container Specification, each doing their thing differently but all compatible and inter-changeable with each other and their images.
- zbyte64 12y agoNo, it is an argument for Docker's workflow. It seems allot of the criticism calling Docker unnecessary overlook how it makes distributing Linux containers as easy as git.
- Alupis 12y agoIs that not one of the criticisms? Downloading an unknown origin image and just blindly trusting it before you start adding your needed components? Creating your own base image is really the only way to ensure the base is trustable. And to that end -- App Container Specification has image discovery and downloading covered[1] [1] https://github.com/appc/spec/blob/master/SPEC.md#app-container-image-discovery https://github.com/appc/spec/blob/master/SPEC.md#app-contain...
- sleepycal 12y agoThanks for sharing, I've seen appc mentioned in a few comments, I'll check it out properly tomorrow. You also raise a good comment about blindly trusting containers which, despite having concerns about this in the past, regrettably I didn't touch on.
- zbyte64 12y agoIf your argument is that it is too easy to share then you are going to have a hard time winning over users. But honestly how hard do you think it is to integrate secure builds into a docker system? I would just stand up a private docker repository and lock the build system to that, problem solved. Or docker could roll out an update to leverage the existing namespaces and combine that with a user controlled whitelist of public key & namespace pairs. The reason docker has enjoyed this much success is because they understand sharing is #1.
- Alupis 12y ago> Or docker could roll out an update to leverage the existing namespaces and combine that with a user controlled whitelist of public key & namespace pairs. Could, but haven't. > The reason docker has enjoyed this much success is because they understand sharing is #1. Except they have fought tooth and nail against a standardized specification until App Container Specification was released. Docker isn't about "sharing", it's about vendor lock-in.