8 ms·
Things to Love About Reddit’s First Transparency Report
- aragot 12y agoGood from EFF to advertise companies who have a good behavior, but what sensitive information does reddit manage? It seems to me like it's only logins and IP addresses, so it's not like they are in charge of emails, maps of where you've been/where you go and personal calendar, is it?
- UnoriginalGuy 12y agoAre how emails different from private messages?
- ipsin 12y agoWait, administrative subpoenas are actually non-binding? I would like to know more. Given how widely they're used in the U.S., spreading the word that you can just ignore them seems like a good idea. If that's true.
- mattbee 12y ago"According to the report, reddit received 33 requests to remove content ... to do with alleged defamation. reddit stood by its users and refused to comply with any of these requests." Good on Reddit for not being swayed, but they'd better keep their servers out of the UK. Here in the "libel capital of the world" hosting providers are treated as co-publishers of allegedly libellous content once we've been notified of it on our network. We _have_ to act, though many complainants don't really understand the precedent and try to hand-wave us into taking down a whole site without giving any specifics. I wrote https://blog.bytemark.co.uk/2010/02/07/adventures-in-libel-or-why-i-wont-read-your-forum https://blog.bytemark.co.uk/2010/02/07/adventures-in-libel-o... in 2010 though Simon Singh's case http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Chiropractic_Association_v_Singh http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Chiropractic_Associatio... was a precedent that improved things.
- jedberg 12y agoThis was a big problem for eBay actually. A UK seller could demand that bad feedback be removed for being libelous.
- revscat 12y agoThat sounds problematic for being able to give honest (but public) feedback when someone has encountered very bad service.
- erglkjahlkh 12y agoAlso, they are not mentioning the cases where the SJW subreddits have terrorized the moderators and admins to delete complete subreddits. It's like if those incidents never existed.
- _delirium 12y agoUnless they did so using subpoenas, court orders, or lawsuits, I don't see how that's relevant to the content of this report? This is just a report about legally mandated takedowns and takedown attempts, not internal reddit moderation policies. That seems to be how other companies' transparency reports also operate. For example, Google's Transparency Report [1] lists information on DMCA takedown requests and other legal proceedings, not sites they've deindexed or penalized due to spam. (They do list malware statistics though.) [1] http://www.google.com/transparencyreport/ http://www.google.com/transparencyreport/
- sergiotapia 12y agoDon't know why your comment is being voted down. It's been known that the Reddit administrators will delete any and everything criticizing tumblr-esque sjw. It's been a long time coming but the mental image I had of Reddit was tarnished. Ideal world: Reddit admins would only delete things that are illegal according to the local laws where their servers are located. Then they would only focus on making sure the platform works and leave the content policing to moderators of individual subreddits.
- mesofile 12y agoKudos to the reddit team for setting a great example. Given the relatively poor resources of the site administrators, hopefully this will help to disprove the idea that transparency is too onerous to be done thoroughly, proactively, and promptly. On a side note, I've been a reddit user for some years but this is the first time I've noticed that the name is preferred un-capitalized.
- tomp 12y agoLet's not forget that Reddit was censoring the Fappening subreddits, along with plenty of other censorship on a smaller scale (usually censoring specific stories in some subreddits, which is done by the moderators of said subreddits, but in the case of default subreddits, it's de facto approved by the company). Sometimes, censorship and privacy attacks by internal actors is as big a threat as external attacks.
- raldi 12y agoAnd other times, the benefits of censorship outweigh the costs. I believe that stolen naked pictures is one of those situations. Moderators "censoring" spam and off-topic submissions is another.
- moomin 12y agoYes, but they don't censor stolen naked pictures, they only censor stolen naked pictures of the famous. Which is truly classy. Free speech on reddit is a privilege of the powerful, not a right of the powerless.
- raldi 12y agoI agree that they should do it for everyone. In fact, I believe they should generalize the rule to "No sexualizing someone without their consent." That takes care of jailbait, creepshots, and thefappening all in one fell swoop. But that's neither here nor there; my point was that not all censorship is wrong, and based on this comment, it seems you agree.
- moomin 12y agoI agree completely, but I also think that it's always worth asking exactly what power structures the "principles" organizations espouse actually support.
- kalleboo 12y agoWhat? They also banned creepshots and similar subs. It's more like they'll be quick to ban things that make noise and make them look bad. There are lots of creepy or illegal small subs, it's not until there's a huge stink made about them that they'll act.
- blahedo 12y agoInteresting: in this article, EFF praises Reddit for its quick publication: "Published within 30 days of the reporting period.... That means more recent, and potentially more relevant data." But in the FAQ about warrant canaries, also published by EFF (and linked from this article), they recommend otherwise: "How often should an ISP publish the warrant canary? Various ISPs have published canaries on a wide range of schedules. To allow time to file a case and for the court to rule on the important legal questions, we suggest at least few months between the transparency report and the time period covered." So it's not really clear what the best practice is here.
- AnkhMorporkian 12y agoReddit has never had a warrant canary, so the recommendations on that page have little bearing on this. Even if reddit did get a couple of NSLs, it gets so many actual requests for information that it grants that there's little reason to have one, especially given that it could report it received 0-249 of them 6 months later anyways.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- UnoriginalGuy 12y agoOne of the things that irks me about current US policing is that police use tactics which imply they have more authority than they have (e.g. administrative subpoenas, demands for information, demands with withhold information, etc) and never (that I know of) get into legal trouble for doing so... In fact in the current system such demands are not only legal but are rewarded. Police will call the resulting evidence "voluntary" even if the company had no idea it was volunteering anything (and thought, often because they didn't hire a lawyer, it was required). Small companies in particular who don't have a staff lawyer, and who don't want to spend a thousand dollars in fees to check an incoming request, are particularly susceptible. Even if they do have a lawyer on retainer, that lawyer may not specialise in this type of law.
- dreamdu5t 12y agoWhy should I care about any of this? Serious question. Transparency is double-speak. It's marketing and branding for the demographic that Reddit caters to. Notifying users of requests by law enforcement that they are legally allowed disclose is just stupid. What matters is the nature of the requests - not the number of them!
- ryanlol 12y agoWhy does this matter? Reddit isn't exactly the kind of company that holds any important data worth a transparency report.
- Maakuth 12y agoHow about an IP address of a user posting something criminal?
- gcb0 12y agofrom a company that makes money by disguising paid posts. yeah. thanks for the hypocrisy.
- username223 12y agoAhem: http://i.imgur.com/FqxKmpX.png http://i.imgur.com/FqxKmpX.png
- flycaliguy 12y agoI'm not entirely sure the comment you are replying to is correct but I believe gcb0 is suggesting that paid posts are blended into reddit seamlessly. Your image clearly shows several differing elements which distinguish an ad from a traditional submission.
- username223 12y agoMy image clearly shows several differing elements which subtly distinguish an ad from a traditional submission. I have trained my ad-blindness to skip the HN ads, usually without even consciously reading the company name, but it took training, just like it takes training to find the tiny "sponsored content" disclaimer elsewhere. That's the point of "native ads" -- to slip in seamlessly with the rest of the content. If HN wanted to advertise openly, it would use a different background color for the ads, and/or clearly label them as such.
- ShadowBan 12y agoThings not to Love About Reddit's First Transparency Report: Condé Nast are very much in bed with various agencies and Reddit is currently employing a blacklist in conjunction with Imgur. It has been comprehensively fish-hooked and tracked - not only is Reddit 'shaping the narrative' when allowing 3rd party reputation management agencies full access to its DB, but they're also employing aggressive MAC / IP traces of their own that will automatically [remove] text from blacklisted MAC / IPs when/if they post. Bonus round: Imgur is also index linked to this (you'll get "failed to upload" errors). Note: these MAC / IPs are independent of Reddit's own moderation policy, and it looks [strong] like they're supplied by .gov or .com 3rd party lists. i.e. You can be blacklisted from Reddit without ever posting on it. (The usual suspects: Environmental groups, social justice, Af.Am. groups - anything but white power groups, which help "shape the opposition" stance). Reddit, at this point, is merely a tool of. Well. Let's just say: I'd have more faith in them if the people running the hounds had any clue about the hare, but they don't. Be Seeing You. p.s. GG / Ghazi rubbish - same people are running it at the top, they're trying to shape something they don't understand. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mcXd6IQpDsQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mcXd6IQpDsQ
- flycaliguy 12y agoI'm don't want to dispute your claim but I definitely want to know how you learned of this and if I can read more about this elsewhere.
- ShadowBan 12y agoGREP Shadow Government END
- eurleif 12y agoHow, exactly, does reddit get anyone's MAC address from outside of their private network?
- ShadowBan 12y agoAs stated: Reddit is being used by "entities" that run their own tracking networks. i.e. the MAC / IPs are supplied as "already black". [hint: ISIL / ISIS / Liveleak etc get white listed automatically] I post, my count is auto = 0. Work it out. We Thought. You. Would. Feel. Happier. As. Yourself. Be. Seeing. You. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V2MIvUx9uiQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V2MIvUx9uiQ
- Fluffers 12y agoC O M P R O M I S E D p.s. This was made before synch was in effect. Oh, and it's Hilarious that HN is now pruning comments. H I L A R I O U S. don't worry. we're coming. muppets.
- RandomCode 12y agoIsn't there a fairness doctrine for broadcast TV? Reddit give no voice to nonatheists. The homos downvote any Christians. Oh, well, dumb fucks.