5 ms·
If you are going to use unauthorized methods to gain content, there is many convenient ways to do so. Most are not effected by DRM. The issue with DRM on video
by belorn 12y ago
If you are going to use unauthorized methods to gain content, there is many convenient ways to do so. Most are not effected by DRM.
The issue with DRM on video is one which lawful consumers of content has to deal with, and those who run programs which is infected by said DRM.
- dredmorbius 12y agoUm. Who elected you god and decided youtube-dl is "unauthorized"? I was actually inquiring as to how such use is impacted by the decision. I've found few or none. Then again, there's little commercial content I've interest in regardless.
- dahdum 12y agobelorn probably figured the terms exclude it, I was curious and checked - seems so. Maybe they've authorized your method specifically somewhere though? http://www.youtube.com/t/terms http://www.youtube.com/t/terms You agree not to access Content through any technology or means other than the video playback pages of the Service itself, the Embeddable Player, or other explicitly authorized means YouTube may designate.
- allendoerfer 12y agoYeah, well, I never confirmed the terms. "By using it, you agree …" is not a binding contract in Germany.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- raldi 12y agoNobody claimed it was a contract violation, or even illegal, just that it was not authorized by YouTube's TOS.
- allendoerfer 12y agoThe first comment actually just said, that it was "unauthorized". By creating a website and making it available on the WWW, you implicitly authorize the user to use a browser to access the website. Which form of browser the user chooses is none of your business. All browsers are therefor always authorized, if you do not restrict the access yourself. Of course some basic laws have been added since the birth of the web. You are not allowed to flood a site with requests and so on. But the principle that browsers and websites are separate entities still applies. If you want full control over your users clients, create your own protocol and your own client. As long as you use open protocols on the web, you implicitly agree to the contracts of the www and have to live with the fact, that the user chooses his client.
- raldi 12y ago> By creating a website and making it available on the WWW, you implicitly authorize the user to use a browser to access the website. By default, yes, but if you then explicitly override that with robots.txt or a TOS, those take precedent. (Again, I'm not talking legally here, just what's been the cultural custom for the past 20 years or so. In other words, if you ignore either and then get banned, I don't think many netizens would shed a tear for you.)
- allendoerfer 12y agoYouTube could do so, but I would argue, that not the user but YouTube behaves as a bad net-citizen then.
- belorn 12y agoIn Sweden, there was a famous case in which this premise was tested. A cable channel gave out a public accessible web link to customers after payment, which then got naturally shared. The cable channel sued the person who shared the link, arguing that it was copyright infringement since it allowed unauthorized users to access the site (case called Canal Plus-fallet). The defense argued that since there was no restriction added to the site, that that meant it was public. The court went with the side of the cable company, even if many commentates disagree. What effect a Swedish case can have on German law depend, but using European court case as guides is quite common in Swedish courts if there is no other prior cases. Same might apply for German courts.
- raldi 12y agoYou don't need to be elected or a god to read the YouTube TOS. Note that the claim was not that it's illegal or unethical or wrong, simply that YouTube itself (rather explicitly) declares that they don't authorize this use of the site.
- GhotiFish 12y agoyoutube's terms forbid the use of unauthorized third party programs to access their services. check out number 5. Content is provided to you AS IS. You may access Content for your information and personal use solely as intended through the provided functionality of the Service and as permitted under these Terms of Service. You shall not download any Content unless you see a “download” or similar link displayed by YouTube on the Service for that Content. The problem is youtube has so many third party applications working with it, that it's smarter for them not to do anything about it. I'm thinking it's the photoshop theory of DRM, just enough to ward off grandma, not enough to prevent photoshop from being replaced as the dominant image manipulation suite.