7 ms·
Having grown up in Houston the zoning issue is definitely something everyone young and old knows about. It's almost part of the ethos. In practice though, it wa
by AndrewKemendo 12y ago
Having grown up in Houston the zoning issue is definitely something everyone young and old knows about. It's almost part of the ethos. In practice though, it was rare to see development that was crazy or so "out of place" that it would have caused problems. That said, places like the Heights and the wards have some interesting character as a result.
I would never move back largely due to the lack of public infrastructure, heat and humidity but the sprawl of the city isn't really a result of poor urban planning but rather seemed to be a function of the cost of real estate and the need to access the oil corridor while also not living in the refinery wasteland to the South east.
- _delirium 12y ago> it was rare to see development that was crazy or so "out of place" Part of that is because, imo, the "no zoning" mythos doesn't really result in practical freedom to develop land however you want. There are two big zoning-like restrictions in practice, which if anything end up with more restrictive land use than many cities which do officially have zoning. The first is that just about all neighborhoods built after WW2 are master-planned communities laid out by one developer (in many parts of Houston, subsidiaries of the various oil companies who were selling off land). These developers built neighborhoods intended to have a particular character, most commonly a suburban-style character, and attached deed restrictions to the properties requiring buyers to maintain that character in perpetuity. This has very similar effects to zoning, in that there are huge swaths of Houston which are by deed restriction not allowed to be redeveloped into anything but single-family homes with a minimum lot size (owners also cannot subdivide their home into rental units). In some ways it's even worse because "rezoning" is even more difficult than usual. Most of these communities do have a way to modify the deeds in principle, but it's all routed through homeowners' association politics, which make regular municipal politics look well-functioning. The second is a big set of development restrictions from the city which, while not precisely zoning, strongly influence what can practically be built. Rules on minimum setbacks, height, and minimum parking really constrain a lot of possible redevelopment.
- AndrewKemendo 12y agoWell exactly, the whole Deed restriction and HOA thing that is rampant is what makes most of Houston's newest developments frustrating to live in.
- chao- 12y agoI'll mirror what you and _delirium have said, but also note that simple economics certainly play a role as well, ala the article. Yes, someone theoretically could buy up the lot across the street from my house, tear down the two houses, and put a gas station in the middle of my cozy little world. But no one will do that because you don't put a gas station in the middle of the block on a side street, or you'll simply go out of business. You put gas stations on a major or semi-major thoroughfare. Some parts of Houston really shine as a demonstration of the adaptability and character of a lack of zoning, and some really do end up worse off for it. And opinions differ, often by what people value in the first place. Plus some areas feel like they're zoned, because a combination of historical designations and private land covenants make them functionally close enough anyway.
- rsync 12y ago"it was rare to see development that was crazy or so "out of place" that it would have caused problems." I was in Houston briefly in 1999. We were driving through a completely residential neighborhood, and someone was running a liquor store out of their porch. They had a house. It was a normal house in a normal neighborhood. That house had a porch. There was an I-shit-you-not liquor store being run from that porch. I would characterize that as "crazy" and also "out of place".