9 ms·
Money quote: "According to Liang himself, he left TSMC after he was passed over for promotion and felt his work was under-appreciated by his former employer."
by ChuckMcM 12y ago
Money quote: "According to Liang himself, he left TSMC after he was passed over for promotion and felt his work was under-appreciated by his former employer."
Which apparently he was, as TSMC argues they are now "losing" millions in revenue because this guy helped Samsung get their 14nm node up. And yet at the time they were unwilling to give him a promotion and/or pay raise. What this argues is that TSMC could have doubled the guys salary and come out ahead by millions. Think about that employers when you start "nickel and diming"[1] the engineers that work for you :-)
[1] American slang for charging (or being charged) in many small and ways which add up to a much larger total later on.
- SolarNet 12y agoThat's a fair assessment, on the other hand, down this road is corporate dystopias and more powerful multinationals. When corporations have no recourse about their knowledge workers leaving and working for a competitor and giving up their IP/Trade Secrets, well companies are going to start to take more drastic measures. It's like the cold war, with scientists defecting back and forth, at some point these companies are going to start have spy/counterintel services if they can't rely on governments to deal with it.
- bsder 12y ago> When corporations have no recourse about their knowledge workers leaving and working for a competitor and giving up their IP/Trade Secrets Companies do have recourse. It's called treating your employees well enough that they don't leave. If your company isn't smart enough to know who is important and how to keep them happy, then your company is going to have problems. Technical staff, especially, tend not to jump for small amounts of money or minor problems. As for technical workers, you simply can't prevent knowledge from leaving when they walk out the door. Especially for things like semiconductor manufacturing research, the knowledge of what was tried and didn't work is often more valuable than the knowledge as to what did work. How in the world would you stop that? Finally, he left in 2011. You're going to have a pretty difficult time convincing me that Samsung's current 14nm node is solely base upon TSMC manufacturing that was only at 28nm at the time. Overall, it sounds like TSMC had an internal political battle over what direction the semiconductor process research should go. Liang lost the battle and left. It seems that Liang was correct from an engineering standpoint, and the folks who stayed behind at TSMC were wrong. Sucks to be TSMC.
- gress 12y agoYou say 'treating their employees well enough that they don't leave' but that ignores the fact that a small number of employees will be able to blackmail the company for millions with the IP they have access to, while regular employees pay the price.
- wombatpm 12y agoyou are right, only CEO's should be able to command those kinds of dollars
- 6d0debc071 12y agoBecause big-wigs would totally pay their regular employees more if their expenses were lower rather than celebrating slightly more profit for themselves?
- abawany 12y agoThey unfortunately have an anti-pattern recourse as well: non-compete agreements. I was presented one today after a few months on the job and it is a doozy. Being in Texas, I am sure the courts will look much more kindly upon its shackles than California has so far. Such is the price of "living free" :).
- hga 12y agoSide note which doesn't affect your point: without "consideration", such as more money, or when you start a job, the job itself, a non-compete is worthless, it's a contract where each side has to gain something. And "keeping your job" isn't one of those. As for California vs. Texas, well, you do get some serious considerations by making a move in either direction. Greater note: I've been convinced for some time that the non-enforcablility of non-competes is "Silicon Valley's" unique advantage. Given the steadily increasing difficulty of doing business in the state, it's almost certainly been critical in keeping that Golden Goose alive and somewhat healthy.
- rgbrenner 12y agoCompanies do have recourse. It's called treating your employees well enough that they don't leave. Except one person is part of a team that produced the IP. So they would always have access to IP worth more than their salary (since salary x NTeamMembers must be <= 100% of the IP value). So even if the team members were paid every dime of the value they've created, a single person would always be able to earn more by stealing IP/trade secrets.
- x0x0 12y agoYet somehow intel, nvidia, amd, and a thousand other companies manage to do just fine in CA, where non-competes are largely unenforceable.
- ChuckMcM 12y agoFunny how that works.
- gaius 12y agoThey do it illegally, the news has been full of it. Eric Schmidt and Steve Jobs were the masterminds who set it up.
- rm445 12y agoCarrying expert knowledge to another company is one thing, but disclosure of trade secrets? Not a lawyer, but I gathered that when trade secrets are properly handled, you have legal recourse against an employee (or ex-employee) who discloses them.
- hga 12y agoIndeed. The only legal basis for non-competes being valid is that they prevent the "first bite of the apple", the damage caused by the first such disclosure of IP, which then requires the harmed company to sue to obtain recourse.
- gcb0 12y agowrong, they should patent it. let the hobbyist learn how they do, and prevent competitors from copying. they tried to have the cake (don't patent, don't publish) and eat it too (not pay people and processes enough to protect your trade secrets)
- chrisbennet 12y agoPatents don't work if they can't be enforced. How would you enforce a manufacturing process if you weren't allowed into your competitors factories? "We have essentially no patents in SpaceX. Our primary long-term competition is in China," said Musk in the interview. "If we published patents, it would be farcical, because the Chinese would just use them as a recipe book."
- gcb0 12y agobut even before that, the issue was the company either tried to be smarter and game the system by not patenting their methods and calling them trade secrets... or maybe it's a new necessity because of China? i don't know. what matter is that either they had patents and with a former employer or not, they can crush Samsung. or if they tried to be opportunistic and threat it as trade secrets to game patents expirations or need to publish methods... than they should just shut up and lament not paying that guy more.