4 ms·
> I honestly don't mind if the staff packing shipping boxes gets paid the same as I do designing new robots You may not mind, but this sort of salary system wo
by TulliusCicero 12y ago
> I honestly don't mind if the staff packing shipping boxes gets paid the same as I do designing new robots
You may not mind, but this sort of salary system would undoubtedly make it very difficult to attract people to more senior, in-demand positions. If the going rate for a highly experienced robotics engineer is 300k, and you can only offer 100k because you can't afford to pay everyone 300k, it will be nearly impossible to fill the position.
- TaylorAlexander 12y agoCertainly this model makes some things more difficult. That is kind of unavoidable when you do things totally differently. There will be pros and cons any time you choose one approach over another. However, this problem isn't insurmountable. The members of the collective could all agree to pay certain bonuses to highly productive members, or everyone could agree to give more productive members more time off. Alternatively, we could only hire people like me. If you want to make the most money, go work for a traditional exploitative company with a lot of extra money. If you want to live with a clean conscience, take less pay. Teachers do this for example. They teach because they care even though the salary is less. A tech coop could offer better pay than teaching with similar non-monetary benefits. We will never end exploitation as long as everyone focuses solely on maximum profit, but if anyone out there wants something different we will find them. I am not saying this is guaranteed to succeed but that it is worth trying. Elon Musk didn't think SpaceX would succeed but he knew it was worth trying even if he lost all his money. Not trying the coop model means accepting the status quo of exploitation, and I'm not sure I can do that.
- Meekro 12y agoCould you explain all this again, or link me to an explanation that goes over all this from start to finish? Because I'm still scratching my head. You say that a company that pays me what the market says I'm worth, is "exploitative." Your coop won't exploit me, and results in me earning less. So why are they the exploiters again, and not you?
- TaylorAlexander 12y agoActually if a normal company is to make a profit off of you, you will get paid less than what you are worth to them. There are some market forces at play that determine typical worker's pay, but they aren't really tied to what you are worth and are instead the smallest fraction of your worth the company can get away with based on what other companies offer. Because of the nature of profit seeking companies, this fraction is always dropping in a healthy market. WalMart workers, for example, are not paid what they are "worth" or the company would make zero profit on their labor. It is a frustrating misconception that workers in a capitalist market get paid what they are worth. In a coop, many people will get paid more than they would otherwise, as no one gets paid starvation wages unlike most companies in the US. Highly productive workers may get paid less in a coop than in a typically arranged company however because typical companies exploit the workers at the very bottom in order to reserve more money for those at the top. It is possible for highly technical workers to get paid more in a coop though. Apple's latest profits were something like $750k per worker per quarter (this includes apple store employees), though clearly they are exceptional. If a coop does very well, they could easily provide more money to all workers than the typical pay of a highly successful company. A coop that makes a lot of money can also contract out some work to coops that make less money, thereby taking advantage of cheaper labor without relying on exploitation of workers. A coop that ships boxes will earn less per worker than a coop that designs robots, but such a system is generally more fair to workers. So some people may get paid less than normal but most would get paid more. Traditional companies can afford to pay more to those at the top by exploiting those at the bottom. This does not happen in a coop.
- Meekro 12y agoI don't think it's a misconception that workers get paid what they are worth. In a capitalist system, something is only "worth" as much as someone is willing to pay for it. Few people question this notion when we're talking about the price of gold or stock market shares, but it's true of labor as well. From what I understand, Marx's definition of exploitation involves companies paying some workers less than what the fruits of their labor are worth. For example, McDonalds might pay an employee $9 an hour while getting $12 an hour in revenue from that employee's work. But, it sounds to me like your coop would be guilty of the same thing. To take an extreme example, suppose your coop includes a janitor and a heart surgeon. Both used to work as independent contractors and bill for their time to whoever needed work done, and now your coop sends the bills and takes in the money. Before joining your coop, the janitor was making $8.50 an hour and the surgeon, $500 an hour. The coop now pulls in $508.50 an hour and gets to decide how to distribute it. I gather from your comments that you find income inequality and starvation wages to be undesirable things. Therefore, you equalize things somewhat and give the janitor $20 an hour and the surgeon $488.50. Now, haven't you committed the same sin as the exploitative companies, namely paying an individual less than the fruits of their labor have produced?
- spiralpolitik 12y agoOrganizing as a cooperative does not necessary mean that everybody is paid the same. For example John Lewis a large UK high street retailer is organized as a cooperative and limits the highest earner salary to x75 the lowest salary (the current chairman is at x60), and bonuses are distributed in an equitable manner.