4 ms·
Not all anti-vaxers are stupid or ignorant, some of them simply have a different quality metric. I've had extensive correspondence with a former colleague who
by lisper 12y ago
Not all anti-vaxers are stupid or ignorant, some of them simply have a different quality metric. I've had extensive correspondence with a former colleague who fully accepts all the science, but simply believes that natural immunity is "better" than artificial immunity, and that a 0.1% mortality rate (which is about what measles produces) is an acceptable price to pay. We both accept the science, but he likes the odds and I don't. I have no idea what to say to someone like that.
- john_b 12y agoTell him that he has no right to make that choice for others, and while he may think he is only making that choice for his own family he is also choosing to put others at a greater risk. The braking analogy in this article is quite apt. Prior to the measles vaccine, about 3-4 million people got measles every year. In such a world, a 0.1% mortality rate still leaves 3000-4000 people dead from an easily preventable disease. And this says nothing of the people who suffer from it but don't die. The economic costs from kids and parents getting sick and missing school and work would total in the hundreds of millions of dollars. Even intelligent people can be narrow-minded. There is much more to a disease than its mortality rate.
- lisper 12y agoHe's fully aware of the impact his decision has on other people. Like I said, he's simply willing to accept a 0.1% child mortality rate as the price you have to pay for the benefit of natural immunity. A minority has to die so that the majority can have a better quality of life. It's a defensible position.
- DanBC 12y agoIt's a nonsensical position. People do not have "natural immunity" to measles. They develop an immunity after contact with live measles in the form of disease or dead measles in the form of a vaccine. The difference between the two is not just the greater risk of death from measles the disease, but also the risk of blindness. It's bad enough that he's not taking that risk himself, but foisting it on his children. And, worse, on the rest of society.
- lisper 12y ago> People do not have "natural immunity" to measles. Yes, we both know that. What he means by "natural immunity" is the immunity that you get by actually contracting the measles and surviving.
- GhotiFish 12y agoin regards to the person your responding to: It's not nonsensical at all. His friend is arguing that if we accept losses to disease then the following humans will be the more resilient ones. however, I thought I would mention a rather fatal flaw in this argument: There is no guarantee that humans that can survive diseases like the measles will be "stronger" than humans who can not. For example, Sickle cell anemia, a genetic disease, is an ADAPTION to survive malaria. It's an intentional sacrifice. Bacteria that adapt to anti-biotics arn't necessarily stronger than bacteria who did not adapt. Adapted bacteria make sacrifices to survive a hostile agent, they don't get it for free. So attempting to immunize humans by breeding them to be resistant/immune has no guarantee to make humans stronger. It's possible the change required could be entirely benign, or it could be catastrophic.
- michael_h 12y agoYou could go Socratic method on him: You: "How does natural immunity work?" They: "You get really miserable and sick and...something something antibodies and maybe t-cells" You: "Oh, I see...and vaccines work differently?" They: "Well, vaccines are made of, uh, weakened or dead virus cells that induce the creation of, hmmm, antibodies...and maybe t-cells." You: "Those sound really similar" They: "Yes, but natural immunity is *stronger* and *more complete*." You: "It is?" Any whiff of patronizing in your voice will invalidate any progress you make. There will be no satisfying payoff for you on this - they will never outright admit that you've convinced them. You're just planting the seed of 'Oh crap, this doesn't really make sense'. > Not all anti-vaxers are stupid or ignorant Maybe not stupid, but ignorant...'liking the odds' of not vaccinating is the same as 'not knowing statistical methods'.
- hga 12y agoActually, it depends on the vaccine, and even killed virus strains aren't going to present all the antigens that a "healthy" or attenuated vaccine virus does. We're already noting that the acellular pertussis (whooping cough) vaccine doesn't do as good a job as the old "witch's brew" variety. Wikipedia right now says: Acellular pertussis vaccine (aP) with three or more antigens prevents around 85% of typical whooping cough cases in children. It has higher or similar efficacy to the previously-used whole cell pertussis vaccine, however the efficacy of the acellular vaccine declines faster. That said, this posture is still an example of amoral familism, and should be dealt with as such, e.g. exile.
- lisper 12y agoI assure you this person is not ignorant, and he understands statistics and how vaccines works. He really is just choosing a different risk posture than most people do.
- michael_h 12y ago> He really is just choosing a different risk posture than most people do. 'different' being 'higher', sure. He doesn't understand statistics. Take measles: If you happen to contract measles, you have about 0.001% chance of getting measles encephalitis which can kill you in a day or so. Extreme situation for sure, but the game then becomes reducing the total number of people roaming around with any form of measles. When you look a graph of the number of measles cases over time, you can easily see when the measles vaccine was introduced (just by eyeballing it). The vaccine unequivocally works effectively. Severe risks associated with the vaccine? About 0.000001%, which is low enough that it is probably not the fault of the vaccine. Result: statistics decimates arguments against the measles vaccine. The only reason he can even make a quantum of a argument is because the population at large has gotten the vaccine and so his selfishness is not as noticeable.
- nzp 12y agoNope. You don't both accept the science, you do, he doesn't. He believes that natural immunity is better than "artificial" immunity. That's plain nonsense, absolutely no science there. Also, with measles, it's not just the mortality rate, it's also about the grave side effects for those who do survive. He just says he accepts the science, but it's all empty words to make sticking head into the ground easier for him.
- lisper 12y ago> He believes that natural immunity is better than "artificial" immunity. That's plain nonsense, absolutely no science there. No, that's not true. There actually is some evidence that naturally acquired immunity is stronger and lasts longer than vaccine-acquired immunity. It is also arguable (and he does argue) that interfering too much with natural selection can have unforeseen but wide-ranging negative consequences in the future.