6 ms·
> the smaller farms that make up a larger portion of our farming infrastructure Really? Do you have a citation for this? All the data I have seen says that s
by bsder 12y ago
> the smaller farms that make up a larger portion of our farming infrastructure
Really? Do you have a citation for this?
All the data I have seen says that small farmers are basically nil in terms of production, profitability, and land area relative to the big mega farms.
- patmcguire 12y ago"In 2011, 96 percent of U.S. crop farms were family farms, and they accounted for 87 percent of the value of crop production." http://www.ers.usda.gov/media/1156726/err152.pdf http://www.ers.usda.gov/media/1156726/err152.pdf And since the devil's in the definitions: "ERS defines a family farm to be one in which the principal operator, and people related to the principal operator by blood or marriage, own more than half of the farm business" So I think that's valid.
- mememememe3 12y agoThe PDF you linked is about how farms are much larger now. The family thing is what you responded to, but the actual pdf does state that small farms have gone or are going away. The previous comments were about small family farms, not just 'family' farms.
- patmcguire 12y agoYeah, you're right, I got caught up in the "operator" language, thought it meant more direct management. I couldn't find any place that did something like cumulative acreage by size that you see with income, i.e. top 5% of farms have half the land.
- ghshephard 12y agoDefinitions are everything here - what are considered "smaller farms?" - My cousin in Alberta, her husband, and two kids with occasional contract help farms two sections (1280 acres) of various crops - and his role in the harvest/planter (outside of parking, which is epic when he has a full set of fertilizing tanks connected) seems to be predominantly supervisory - GPS and software-defined systems do most of the actual work now. He even has a mini-fridge in his Air-Conditioned Cab. Would we consider that to be a smaller farm?
- Retric 12y ago4% of crop land is outside of family farms any they produced 13% of crop value? That suggests family farms on average suck. However the definition of "family farm" tends to get stretched a lot. 50,000+ accre "Family Farms" are hardly what most people think of as family farms. Eighty-three percent of cropland was on farms that were larger than the mean size, and 71 percent was on farms that were more than twice (1,100 being the meadean). Also of note, a lot of "Farms" are really only farms in name only. Hay production for example qualifies even if you outsource harvesting to someone else. Happen to own a large field well it's easy to make some money on the side even if someone else does all the work and it barely covers taxes.
- Houshalter 12y ago>4% of crop land is outside of family farms any they produced 13% of crop value? That suggests family farms on average suck. No, it means the distribution of crops isn't the same, which isn't surprising. Perhaps corporate farms are more likely to produce profitable crops like vegetables or fruit or something.
- bsder 12y agoFrom your reference, while there are a ton of small farms (median size 45 acres), the vast majority of cropland is on large farms. Even if I concede less than 100 acres as a "small farm" (and 100 acres is almost twice the median farm size), that represents almost 66.4% of the total number of farms yet only 8.4% of total production. Small farms are not a rounding error, but they sure are headed that direction.
- dredmorbius 12y ago"Family farm" includes large family-owned businesses. Given that some of the largest businesses in the US are privately (largely family)-held, that's a pretty meaningless distinction. Koch Industries, Cargill, and the SAS Institute all come to mind. Forbes has a list of the top 20: http://www.forbes.com/lists/2011/21/private-companies-11_land.html http://www.forbes.com/lists/2011/21/private-companies-11_lan... Far better to classify total land holdings by farm size.
- maxerickson 12y agoCensus has reports about that stuff: http://www.census.gov/compendia/statab/cats/agriculture/farms_and_farmland.html http://www.census.gov/compendia/statab/cats/agriculture/farm... 827 is instructive: http://www.census.gov/compendia/statab/2012/tables/12s0827.pdf http://www.census.gov/compendia/statab/2012/tables/12s0827.p... More than 1/3 of harvested acres come from farms larger than 2000 acres (of which there are ~80). Farms larger than 500 acres account for roughly another 1/3 of harvested acres. Of the remainder, about half of acreage is harvested on farms larger than 260 acres. There are some huge land holders in that top category (the mean harvested acres is 1.5 million, the mean land ownership is ~4x that).
- bryanlarsen 12y agoIn some places in the US & Canada, 2000 acres is a pretty small farm. I know a guy in Saskatchewan who farms 1600 acres and holds a full time off-farm job as well. I also know of a family ranch in Saskatchewan that's about 30,000 acres. It's run by a husband, wife and two hired hands.
- maxerickson 12y agoThe report I linked distinguishes between acres and harvested acres, except for the 4x, I'm quoting the harvested acres. So I think graze land and such is not going to show up in those numbers. I made a stupid mistake, there are 80,000 large farms, not 80. Damn it. At least that makes a lot more sense.
- 12y ago
- cwbrandsma 12y agoI'm also a farm kid. I think the problem is defining what is a small farm vs a large farm. And that definition will change depending one what part of the country you are in. A small dairy by me is anything less than 1000 milking head of cows. A small farm is less than 1500 acres (5000 acres is common). In a different region, 300 milking head is large, so is 500 acres of farm ground.
- ghshephard 12y ago5,000 acres is common? Are there family farms that are that large, or are those corporate farms. I've never heard of a family farm that was 8 sections large - so presumably these are corporate farms?
- Trisell 12y agoMy grandparents own 5000 acres, of which they used to farm around 3000 acres of that actively. And we managed all of that with my grandfather, a hired hand, and myself in the summer, and just my grandfather and the hired hand during the winter. We did a 2000 acre wheat harvest, and 4 cuttings of hay at a 1000 acres a cutting in the summer from June through September. I worked 12 hour days during the summer from the time I was 12 until I was 17.
- trhway 12y ago>And we managed all of that with my grandfather, a hired hand, and myself in the summer, and just my grandfather and the hired hand during the winter. well, i see one more time how USSR planned collective economy sucked compare to the US farming - a USSR collective farm of 10-20K acres would contain 200-300 households with most working age people of the households employed at the farm.
- timonovici 12y agoThen you understand nothing of how URSS actually worked. They didn't "employed" 300 people because they were needed, they did so to keep everyone busy. The head of a "colhoz" (I think that would roughly translate to "farm"), sometimes had to make up stuff, just keep people busy, and write the hours on paper.