3 ms·
Your reasoning might be valid if authors didn't stand on the shoulders of existing culture.
by CamperBob2 12y ago
Your reasoning might be valid if authors didn't stand on the shoulders of existing culture.
- tptacek 12y agoIn what profession do people not stand on the shoulders of others?
- CamperBob2 12y agoReal estate, for one valid response to rayiner's non sequitur. ("Land is passed down from generation to generation, and few people ask: 'what's the empirically justifiable duration of land rights?'") Copyrighted material is the ultimate example of "You didn't build that." That's why it's a temporary bargain with the public domain, and not an entitlement.
- rayiner 12y agoUh, real estate is much less "you didn't build that" than Harry Potter. You're almost certainly not the one who brought your land out of the wilderness, cleared and leveled it, etc.
- CamperBob2 12y agoThe point is, the underlying real estate was not created by anyone else (subject of course to one's preferred religion.) Compare what a real estate developer does to what a Disney-esque media conglomerate does. The developer buys the land and constructs buildings for customers who are entitled to exactly what's in the contract, nothing more or less. I have no problem with that. Nobody took anything that wasn't legally theirs (at least not recently). If you lease the building, nobody is going to alter the contract after the fact to extend the lease for 70 more years, or kick you out before the agreed-upon term is up. Disney, on the other hand, appropriates stories and ideas from our shared culture and erects legal walls around them. They didn't build jack shit, they just slapped on a fresh coat of paint and a stout padlock. They're cultural squatters with their own cadre of Congressmen.