3 ms·
That's just not true. The direction of IT certainly is set by upper management, as well as the budget. If IT says 'we need an IDS' and management says 'it's not
by freehunter 12y ago
That's just not true. The direction of IT certainly is set by upper management, as well as the budget. If IT says 'we need an IDS' and management says 'it's not in the budget', what can IT do about it? If IT says 'it will take this long and this much money to change our password policy' and management say 'work on new things, not changing old things', what can IT do about it?
Senior management might not directly set the password policy, but they do say what you should work on, and by proxy, what you're not going to have the time to work on. And besides, what is the role of management if not keeping track of their employees? If an employee fucks up that bad, it's their managers fault.
And yes, if the accounting department was that incompetent, SOX says it's senior management's fault. That's what the yearly attestation is for.
- cm2187 12y agoWell, somehow engineers and architects manage to resist management pressures in favor for security, you don't see many bridges collapsing but they have financial constraints too. And accountants resist management pressures to bend the accounting standard, or they go to prison too. IT is in many respect an unregulated profession. Pretty much anyone can declare himself a programmer. There are some regulations on certain systems but not on people. I am not a fan of regulation but the current pace of data breaches is just unacceptable. If we don't find a solution, some old lawmaker will.
- freehunter 12y agoThere are certain regulations about IT, enforced not by the government but by private companies (such as PCI). I'm just going to have to disagree with you and move on about regulating the people, though. I see your point, but I just don't agree. If anything, I feel managers should be regulated, so they are only allowed to oversee positions where they have the knowledge to fully understand what their direct reports are doing, from front-line to c-level. That's what I feel is the problem. SOX isn't a regulation of the programmer, it's a verification that his management actually doing their job overseeing him.
- cm2187 12y agoI am not saying that regulation is desirable. In fact it is going to be a major obstacle to innovation. What I am saying is that we pretty much see a major data breach every week. There are some instances where one can call them force majeure, like a zero day on a major security component in windows or linux. But there is no excuse for SQL injections vulnerabilities, unencrypted personal data, IT professionals logging-in to websites without checking the URL, unpatched systems, etc. Complaining about budgets to fix these issues is like saying that the problems with collapsing bridges is that we don't spend enough fixing the structure. Well, it should have been built properly in the first place. Yes, resources will have to be allocated to fix existing systems but I think the problem here is more fundamental than a problem of budget and management focus. We need to have a profession competent enough to build a bridge structurally sound even with average engineers. And this is a general comment. We don't know yet how this particular breach happened.
- llama052 12y ago"Complaining about budgets to fix these issues is like saying that the problems with collapsing bridges is that we don't spend enough fixing the structure. Well, it should have been built properly in the first place." I'd like to think that engineers do want to build things properly, however to build something properly it usually involves more resources. The problem is when it comes down to brass tax the low bidder wins. I've worked in many big companies over many years, and yes I've hacked things together MANY times because of budget/time constraints. A lot of it was because of Management wanting to come under budget, or because they wanted to rush the product to be a hero. I don't get where this idea comes from that engineers just want to do things in the worst way, do you think a doctor wants to kill his patients or do something that would endanger the patient if they didn't have to?
- cm2187 12y agoI am not questioning intention. I am questioning competence.
- Terr_ 12y ago> Well, somehow engineers and architects manage to resist management pressures in favor for security When this does happen, it's often because management's "security" request is either nonsensical--based on some puff piece they saw in an airport magazine--or they won't accept the necessary financial-costs/organizational-changes of doing it right. It's no coincidence that the people with the most exemptions from security policy are usually the upper management.
- BrandonMarc 12y ago> Well, somehow engineers and architects manage to resist management pressures in favor for security, you don't see many bridges collapsing but they have financial constraints too. And accountants resist management pressures to bend the accounting standard, or they go to prison too. Generally, yes, but not always. Sometimes they get boxed in by management and forced to make bad choices. When this happens, it usually leads to a spectacular failure ... and then the scapegoat is found. The most famous case is probably the Challenger space shuttle. At Texas A&M they make sure every engineering student reads the story [1] of the Morton Thiokol employees assessing whether or not it was safe to launch at such low temperatures. The engineers had solid doubts, and refused to declare it safe. The managers had pressure from every direction to get to "yes" and launch the bird already. Finally, during the teleconference the night before, one of the engineers' superiors said "Take off your engineering hat and put on your management hat." A new recommendation was put out (bypassing the engineers who still refused to sign off), and the next morning they got their launch like they wanted. Just over a minute later the shuttle exploded, killing the crew and putting American manned spaceflight on a multi-year hiatus. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- [1] http://ethics.tamu.edu/Portals/3/Case%20Studies/Shuttle.pdf http://ethics.tamu.edu/Portals/3/Case%20Studies/Shuttle.pdf
- cm2187 12y agoThere are always cases like this in every profession. Some dam in Italy which collapsed for a similar reason, incompetent doctors, Enron, etc. But when you go see your doctor, you do not rely on the fact that he is one of the best doctors in the US. You have no way to tell. You rely on the fact that even an average doctor is good enough to not miss something important. Well the problem with IT security as it is now, is that we see major breaches almost every week. Some were difficult to avoid but in many case it is just because of bad security design, and in some case people developers ignoring completely security. And I am sure Sony's management didn't box the developers in storing passwords in clear text.