5 ms·
Calling a spade a spade: Mathematics in the new pattern of division of labour [pdf]
- ajuc 12y agoVery good analysis. I think free university education is part of the solution. It forces people to get over the neck of the hourglass (because all the competitors will have a degree). Yes it leads to worse level of university education, you cannot avoid that, but as long as it's over the neck - it will allow people to learn more on their own (we have internet after all), and they will have motivation. This works in Poland (big unemployement 20 years ago might have been a big factor too - everybody knew that your kids must learn English and get M.A. if they want to have a job). We had period where "you aint gonna need it" approach to math education was winning (they even made math optional in the final high-school exam), but in the end everybody realised it was a mistake. The only problem with this model is - it's hard to get the best scientists to teach math to everybody. And hard to make public universities be able to afford the best scientists at all. So this model produces huge amount of reasonably educated engineers, programmers, economists, analists etc, but it produces few world-class scientists.
- TeMPOraL 12y ago> This works in Poland (big unemployement 20 years ago might have been a big factor too - everybody knew that your kids must learn English and get M.A. if they want to have a job). A sad side-effect of this is that we have tons of unemployed M.A.s of humanities - everybody knew that their kids need to get an M.A., but not much thought was applied towards what kind of M.A. could be useful. But this can be attributed to a generation of people discovering for the first time how the whole capitalism thing works. It's a problem with social expectations, not with free universities, of course.
- theorique 12y agoThat tends to be one of the challenges with credentialism and inflation. In the 1960s or 1970s (at least in the USA), the mindset among employers tended to be "you've got a degree? you're HIRED!" - they just needed reasonably smart people and university acted as a filter. The parents of Millennials were among this cohort and internalized this mindset (along with the society at large). The idea of "more education = better job opportunity" has lasted for the past 40-50 years and even been escalated.
- innguest 12y ago> they just needed reasonably smart people and university acted as a filter Bingo. That's all most employers are looking for. If employers in the US were allowed to do IQ tests on candidates, no one would care what degrees you have.
- HillRat 12y agoIt will be interesting -- and by "interesting" I mean "terrifying" -- to see what the thwarting of internalized expectations does to our social fabric. It's the same essential motivation that fueled the rise of Islamist terror groups in the Mideast: young men with education but no financial or social prospects. Obviously, these were societies with threadbare social fabric due to decades of political repression and economic mismanagement, but there's no ironclad rule that an otherwise stable country can't tip over with shocking speed. (In this, the sheer size of the US probably creates a tendency towards short-term stability, while also making it more difficult to enact long-term solutions.) The post-war economic ideal of America was a powerful albeit somewhat utopian concept -- a large number of financially-secure skilled and unskilled laborers supporting a smaller but still large upper middle-class of "symbolic manipulators" for whom a college degree served as an entrance ticket. The lure was, of course, that anyone could move up the ladder if they applied themselves, worked hard, and got an education. The post-war social compact offered stability and meritocratic advancement in exchange for sociopolitical legitimation. Stability was swept away by automation and globalization, and advancement is, for all but the most elite, tenuous at best; what, then, will we replace it with?
- chetanahuja 12y ago
- MatrixGroups 12y agoFunny/sad part is that we are not even talking about "real math" as practiced by mathematicians, rather down-to-earth utilitarian kind that lets you get by in your day-to-day activities. I blame the parents who, of course, know better than everyone else and the "experts" that engage in populist games.
- j2kun 12y agoA lot of his arguments are backed by the assertion that "The majority of British math major graduates can't do X." As I can attest at the US polytechnic university I graduated from, graduation is not necessarily the best measure of the success of an education system. This is especially true for math majors, most of whom decide partway to disengage from the thinking part of mathematics and turn to teaching. It's no secret why: they thought math in university would be a continuation of math in high school, and when they are instead asked to think hard about linear algebra or topology or analysis, they decide they don't like math after all. Such students have special, easier courses and yet get the same degree as the top students in their department.
- dev1n 12y agoIn support of this, in high school I didn't quite find math interesting. Once I got into the higher level courses in college I became enthralled in linear algebra and probability theory. Unfortunately it took until my senior year before this occurred (graduated bs in cs). This article helps provide a basis for greater variety of math courses in high school IMO. p.s. j2kun your blog is awesome! Your introduction to the math behind PageRank introduced me to the world of linear algebra and I have truly enjoyed the adventure it has set me on. Thank you!
- jeffreyrogers 12y agoThis was my experience as well, though fortunately I found out math was actually interesting my junior rather than senior year.
- tsotha 12y agoI went the engineering route and I'm glad I did. Originally it was a toss-up between math (which I enjoyed in high school) and EE, but since a lot of math grads seem to go into teaching and I have nowhere near enough patience to teach, I went into engineering. As part of EE I had to take statistics and linear algebra, plus enough calculus to understand surface and line integrals. I hated it. If I'd gone math I would ended up being just that kind of "disengage from the thinking part" person.
- j2kun 12y agoThis quote resonates with me > I am old enough to have been taught, in my teenage years, to write computer code in physical addresses, that is, sequences of zeroes and ones, each sequence referring to a particular memory cell in the computer. My colleague, an IT expert, told me recently that he and people who work for him passed in their lives through 6 changes of paradigms of computer programming. In many walks of life, to have a happy and satisfying professional career, one has to be future-proof by being able to re-learn the craft, to change his/her way of thinking. How can this skill of changing one’s way of thinking be acquired and nurtured? At school level—mostly by learning mathematics.
- graycat 12y agoThe OP sees countries around the world and essentially all of current civilization as neglecting math and regards this situation as unfortunate. Mostly I don't and for the following two reasons: (1) Learning Math? Whatever K-12 or four years of college do in math, it's quite possible to learn quite a lot of math. So, I see no big disaster here. That is, if someone wants to learn some math, they can go for it. E.g., there is an outline of how in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8998893 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8998893 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8998922 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8998922 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8998938 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8998938 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8269324 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8269324 Further, the Internet is just awash in materials for learning math, the best of which are just terrific. Further, there is no shortage of really good math expertise in at least the top two dozen or so US research universities. And there are engineering schools with programs in the mathematical sciences with optimization, probability, statistics, numerical analysis, and more. Some EE departments are deep into stochastic processes, signal processing, stochastic integration, and more. Since I did a lot of such learning, it's doable. (2) Math for the Economy? If some math has some economic value, then do a start up where the crucial core, secret sauce of the start up is the math. Right: As the OP makes clear, in principle and with some examples, and with more being possible, the founder of the start up can do the math, and millions of user/customers can make use of the results without being aware of the math at all. Since I'm trying to do just such a start up, maybe such is doable. For the role of math, don't see any biggie problems, for national security, economies, countries, or civilization. There are a lot of really good mathematicians. In part what's missing are their $40 million houses, 300 foot yachts, private Gulfstream jets, two dozen Ferraris, drop dead gorgeous trophy spouses, etc. So, right, there's James Simons. And Andrew Viterbi. But, we need many hundreds more. I'm working on it, and one thing the OP might do that would be more effective would be to show how he used math to get a 300 foot yacht, etc.
- wwweston 12y ago> banks and insurance companies clamour for “numerate” workforce, but prefer to deal with innumerate customers And, honestly, they also prefer to isolate numerate expertise in a few "cost centers" inside their operation. Years ago I held a number of bonds my grandparents had bought for me as a gift (and educational tool) when I was a young child. I'd studied enough mathematics that I could derive compounding interest formulas and enough finance I thought I understood the instrument. But the bond values I calculated and the values my bank would redeem them for diverged enough that I wondered. So I asked if I could talk with anyone at the bank about why their calculated values were different from mine. I wanted either higher redemption values or an education. I had a brief conversation with a customer facing local officer where I started to explain. It was over quickly; the officer was polite, but clearly uninterested in following (much less enlightening) any conversation about the specific computation of bond values. And very sure that whoever had done it had done it correctly, and that was all that was necessary.
- ky3 12y agoIllegitimi non carborundorum. Write a letter to HQ. Write a letter to the newspapers. Persist and publish their formula. That may not have been the exact path of education that your grandparents had in mind. But if you muster the derring-do for the task, you'd make them very proud and blessed that they had you as a grandchild!
- varelse 12y agoWhen I was in college and grad school, I noticed that students who couldn't hack Calculus, Linear Algebra, Differential Equations, and Statistics were also the ones struggling with science courses. In my undergrad years, this came to a head in General Physics where understanding the concepts of derivatives and integrals are crucial to seeing it as anything but disjoint plug and chug memorization of equations. In grad school, these were the ones booted with a masters after candidacy exams or even sooner. These days, getting a B in all those courses and reading a book on Python or Java is sufficient to get a six figure position in the tech industry(1) whilst the remainder of science grads I know struggle through endless post-docs and non-tenure track positions hoping things will get better. I only know one fellow student (out of hundreds) who eventually made tenure. I learned long division in elementary school. If the ability to grasp long division has become the new dividing line between the haves and the have-nots, we IMO are in deep doodoo as a nation. And as others have posted here, between Khan Academy, Coursera, Udacity and a bajillion blog posts, it's never too late to learn, and at some point we ought to stop making excuses for people who can bootstrap their way out of innumeracy(2). It's not that much to ask here, is it? 1. And yet live below the poverty line in SF or NYC 2. Assuming they can even read, and if they can't, we need a frickin' Manhattan Project to change that