5 ms·
Who defines harassment? I've seen someone be banned from Twitter for criticising someone they've never even contacted. The Verge, in one article, along with act
by nailer 12y ago
Who defines harassment? I've seen someone be banned from Twitter for criticising someone they've never even contacted. The Verge, in one article, along with actual threats, said a person who did not threaten but simply insulted another person was a harasser. People in arguments publish other people's phone numbers to a few thousand followers, they'll drop off and then come online again. AFAICT the argument goes that if you insult someone, it's 'calling them out' but if someone insults you it's 'harassment'.
- AndrewDucker 12y agoThis is: http://wilwheaton.tumblr.com/post/110134860037/one-week-of-harassment-on-twitter http://wilwheaton.tumblr.com/post/110134860037/one-week-of-h...
- pgeorgi 12y agoIncluding "Fuck off."? That's not exactly a literary marvel, and far from civilized discourse. But harassment?
- hedwall 12y agoYou read all that harassment and the only thing you can comment on is the one "Fuck Off" included there?
- pgeorgi 12y agoI _can_ comment on all the other statements cited on that page. But others already did, so why should I repeat more of the same? "This is [harassment]" meant all of it, incl. the one I referred to (and a bunch of others that may be angry disagreement, but are not violent, and not necessarily harassment). Comes to show that the definition of harassment isn't as easy as "here's a list". Since you asked so nicely, to give you a comment on all those other posts, let me stick to those who are unquestionably harassment - those containing threats of violence and death (I just don't feel like arguing about a more precise definition with a random internet stranger right now): It's kind of amazing how limited the vocabulary and breadth is in those statements. It's essentially the same 4 or 5 insults and threats reiterated again and again and again, with the most variability in the order of words - any resemblance of grammar is obviously optional in the first place. So when I first saw that collection (a couple of days ago, so I'm not rage-struck anymore - maybe that explains why I'm not joining the chorus), I was considering if some trolls created tons of throwaway accounts and dug deeper - those are accounts that are primarily used for other purposes, with a wide range of profiles: old accounts, new accounts, students, adults across all professions (as per their bio). All of them with "normal" posts before the one listed there, and after. So trolls creating throw away accounts are out. Since the accounts are still in regular use, it also doesn't look like a massive take over. So there are really two options: 1. these accounts are taken over in some non-intrusive way by aggressors (eg. cross site scripting, reuse of simple to guess password) 2. people across the board (all ages, all professions, all sexes and genders) share such an annoying conduct[0], and it's likely that in your/my/anyone's neighbourhood there are a couple of such people otherwise living normal lives. So, people are monsters, and there's no clear marker to pinpoint them except their conduct. What else is new? [0] I do assume that except two or three deranged people, they leave it at verbal threats like these - which doesn't mean that this is okay, individually or collectively. Besides showing some crass personal flaws, it's just as frightening for the target since they can't know what's real and what's "for show". There's also a real risk that the truly deranged feel encouraged by so many people who seem to be alike on the surface.
- rodgerd 12y agoRight in the article: http://femfreq.tumblr.com/post/109319269825/one-week-of-harassment-on-twitter http://femfreq.tumblr.com/post/109319269825/one-week-of-hara... But frankly, if you're pulling in you anecdote to imply that there's no problem, I doubt you actually give a shit.
- nailer 12y agoThat article is the one mentioned in the post you're replying to. There's actual, horrible threats there, but there's also many people who simply insulted someone else. The Verge seems to think they're equivalent. They're not. The Verge also ignores death threats and postal threats this person's followers have made - as the parent said, when it's the side you like, it's fine, when it's the side you don't, it's harassment. You mentioned I 'pulled in an anecdote and don't give a shit'. Harassment normally involves contacting someone, rather than simply insulting someone, so that case seems quite relevant. Re: 'don't give a shit', I do care about this issue, I can simply see the obvious inconsistencies. I think there's a problem, but not with Twitter the company. I think it's with people who talk about nuanced topics over 140 character sound bytes, and the egos at play on Twitter.
- jarcane 12y agoWhy is verbal abuse always the first battlefield of the internet 'free speech' advocate?
- nailer 12y agoIt's not. I mentioned it because The Verge said insulting someone was 'harassment'. It isn't, either by the common definition or by Twitter's terms of service. A simple test: if you think insults should be considered harassment, would you support your own Twitter account being blocked for insulting someone?
- jarcane 12y agoIf you insult someone on the street, or in their home, what do you think the reaction would be? Insulting someone is harassment. If you made it your mission to relentlessly insult one of your co-workers, how long do you think you'd keep your job? Why is it that the internet deserves 'special consideration' for the allowance of verbal abuse? Nobody owes you the right to call them a cunt.
- bloat 12y agoThe victim defines it.
- pgeorgi 12y agoI feel insulted by that statement. Communication is a rather complex matter and having any single party decide what a given message is supposed to mean misses the point (see for example https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four-sides_model https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four-sides_model). Even simple societies end up appointing judges (impartial or not) to provide an outside view on a conflict, instead of letting the participants decide on any claim's merit.
- AnkhMorporkian 12y agoI have never seen the four-sides model before. That's a fascinating way to decompose a message and its potential receipt. Thanks for sharing!
- bloat 12y agoThat's totally fair. However I feel that considering the current state of harrasment on Twitter, a simple definition is appropriate and will be more effective in practice than a more nuanced approach. I certainly hope Twitter and its trolls clean up their act to a state when we would have the luxury of using impartial judges.
- pgeorgi 12y agoI just don't think "the victim defines it" is a simple definition. It's short, but actually a nightmare to enforce. twitter _does_ have a definition to work with, referred to from their ToS (https://support.twitter.com/articles/20169997-abusive-behavior-policy https://support.twitter.com/articles/20169997-abusive-behavi...), which sounds pretty clear and simple to me and covers most if not all of what femfreq cited. So this sounds like "merely" a compliance issue on twitter's side.
- mdisraeli 12y agoI get your overall point, but in turn you've overlooked the Relationship layer - basic compassion means that the victim gets to make the call as to if something hurt them. If someone is stabbed, do you require empirical measurements of their injury before you accept their pain?
- paublyrne 12y agoIn this case the service provider - Twitter - should define it, since they are responsible for implementing any measures against harassers. Personally, I think any threat of violence - whether this is a realistic threat, or not - should constitute harassment. A lot of the tweets in that link would qualify. I won't repeat them here, but there are a lot of threats that basically say the tweeter will rape and/or kill the receiver.
- nailer 12y ago> In this case the service provider - Twitter - should define it, since they are responsible for implementing any measures against harassers. Agreed 100%. The Verge has a different concept of harassment from Twitter's - you can't report someone on Twitter for merely calling you a 'bitch'. If The Verge wants this changed, they should say so explicitly. They should consider whether they ever insult anyone else. Agreed about threats of violence. Whether to block unrealistic or not, I'm not too sure: Tweets labelled as harassment by The Verge: - 'You're a bitch'. Sorry, insults aren't against Twitter's ToS. - 'You're a waste of oxygen' - not a threat. - 'You deserve to die' - yup. Banhammer.
- chazu 12y agoNot sure why this is being downvoted - diluting the meaning of 'harassment' could have very unfortunate consequences for both victims of REAL harassment as well as the general usefulness of social media. It seems reasonable people should be able to agree on what constitutes harassment and what clickbait factories like gawker and the verge are casting as harassment in the name of ad impressions.