3 ms·
Anyway, in case of AT&T they easily invested in their mobile networks, while telephony there is covered by Title II. Where were their investment fears? Title II
by shmerl 12y ago
Anyway, in case of AT&T they easily invested in their mobile networks, while telephony there is covered by Title II. Where were their investment fears? Title II won't affect any investments - all those arguments are bunk. What it will affect is making ripping everyone off with anticompetitive techniques harder.
- rayiner 12y agoThe statute is written in a way where forbearance from almost all the actual provisions of Title II is written into Title II for wireless carriers. For wireline, Forebearance is at best at the FCC's discretion, and at worst possibly an abuse of the FCC's discretion that'll be overturned in court. Thus, with wireline the carriers face the threat of full-blown Title II which they don't with wireless.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> The statute is written in a way where forbearance from almost all the actual provisions of Title II is written into Title II for wireless carriers. Where? The only thing I can see in the statute that might touch on different treatment regarding wireless carriers actually limits the degree of forbearance that can be applied to "commercial mobile services" in ways that do not apply to other common carriers. compare 47 USC Sec. 332(c)(1) with 47 USC Sec. 160.
- rayiner 12y agoBut 332(c)(2) makes clear that the FCC can apply Title II provisions only to the services that interconnect with the PSTN: http://scholarship.law.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1068&context=commlaw http://scholarship.law.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1068&... (explaining the distinction between commercial mobile service in 332(c)(1) and private mobile service in 332(c)(2)); see also Cello P'ship v. FCC, 700 F.3d 534, 538 (D.C. Cir. 2012) ("In particular, section 332 specifies that providers of "commercial mobile services," such as wireless voice-telephone service, are common carriers, whereas providers of other mobile services are exempt from common carrier status. See id. § 332(d)(3), (c)(2).") Even leaving aside the issue of whether Congress intended to create a voice/data dichotomy: at a purely a technical level, voice and data networks are segregated. LTE only supports packet-switched IP, and unless you're using VoLTE, voice runs over the circuit-switched GSM network.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> But 332(c)(2) makes clear that the FCC can apply Title II provisions only to the services that interconnect with the PSTN But 332(d)(2) explicitly grants the FCC the authority to define, through regulation, what the terms "service that is interconnected with the public switched network" mean in the context of defining whether a service is a "commercial mobile service". Given that there is absolutely a sense in which the internet itself is interconnected with the PSTN through many gateways, its not entirely impossible that part of the the proposal at issue expands the existing regulatory definition of interconnection to include any general-purpose mobile broadband internet service, which would bring such services within the scope subject to common carrier rules. Anyhow, the argument that mobile internet is outside the scope of what may be subject to common carrier status (and thus, Title II regulation) is a different one than the argument you made earlier that there are statutory provisions expressly requiring forbearance from "most provisions" of Title II for mobile services.
- droopybuns 12y agoLawyers cost money. The carriers are clearly going to sue. There is opportunity cost in persuing the lawsuits. You are going to see these lawsuits happening right now, and you are going to not see projects behind the scenes for each carrier which don't get funded because they are investing in lawsuits. These investments arguments are not bunk.
- shmerl 12y agoIf they are ready to waste money on lawsuits and later whine that they don't have money for improving the service because they wasted it on lawsuits - it's really their own fault. They should blame themselves.