4 ms·
The Economist article is written with the presumption that there are are problems that need non-neutrality in order to be solved and that there is thus a tradeo
by wtallis 12y ago
The Economist article is written with the presumption that there are are problems that need non-neutrality in order to be solved and that there is thus a tradeoff of some sort to be made. They cite better network management, and give as examples latency-sensitive applications that suffer from the lack of guaranteed latency.
Those are fallacies. The lack of guaranteed latency is fundamentally no bigger of a problem than the lack of guaranteed bandwidth. Non-neutral traffic shaping is not necessary to maintain good performance, and in practice a best-effort network can achieve acceptable latency for things like VoIP without having to explicitly identify, classify, and prioritize VoIP protocols. ISPs may be accustomed to using such explicit techniques, but neutral alternatives exist and work better for general purpose connections, so we shouldn't carve out any exceptions here.
The Economist also points out the difficulty of determining when traffic is or should be illegal and blockable. It is not at all apparent to me that ISPs have a need to be involved in subjective decisions like that in order for us to have a functional Internet. Is erring on the side of allowing traffic and prosecuting later really going to cause serious problems, or can we come up with an objective set of guidelines for what constitutes a DoS worth blocking?
- seanp2k2 12y agoRe: requirements of ISPs blocking illegal traffic: http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Online_Copyright_Infringement_Liability_Limitation_Act http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Online_Copyright_Infringement... (TL;DR they're exempt, just like e.g. Web hosting companies. It's the "don't shoot the messenger" concept.)
- wtallis 12y agoThat covers copyright infringement but not criminal activity. They haven't explicitly said what they intend to do with section 230, which provides safe harbor for ISPs that try to block obscenities and offensive content.
- AnthonyMouse 12y agoPeople keep using DoS as the canonical example of the need for this, but in that case one of the endpoints is requesting that the traffic be dropped. The ISP isn't making the decision for anybody.
- wtallis 12y agoExcept that there isn't actually a real and usable protocol for pushing drop rules up to your ISP, so in practice you can't authorize your ISP to block a DoS on your behalf without getting humans involved.
- AnthonyMouse 12y agoWhich is why you pretty much always get humans involved. How is the ISP even supposed to know it's a DoS otherwise? Maybe you just made the front page of HN and you want the traffic.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- JonnieCache 12y ago>The Economist article is written with the presumption that there are are problems that need non-neutrality in order to be solved and that there is thus a tradeoff of some sort to be made. This is the absolute classic form of media psychic manipulation: present a false choice and allow endless debate within this window but never question what might lie outside it. Additionally, one side of the debate is accepted as the default and alternatives are only evaluated relative to this one viewpoint. Another current example is the "work life balance" "debate" as it relates to social media. We are constantly told that we should "unplug" and "find time for ourselves," assuming that the majority of the time we are "plugged" and devoting our energies, via elaborate and exciting abstractions, to some distant venture capital fund. One relevant term of art here is the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overton_window https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overton_window
- forgottenpass 12y agoDepending on your taste in writing styles, you might enjoy this: http://thelastpsychiatrist.com/2014/01/randi_zuckerberg.html http://thelastpsychiatrist.com/2014/01/randi_zuckerberg.html
- coldpie 12y ago> It is not at all apparent to me that ISPs have a need to be involved in subjective decisions like [determining when traffic is or should be illegal and blockable] What makes you think they are or would be under this proposal? The announcement said, "These enforceable, bright-line rules will ban paid prioritization, and the blocking and throttling of lawful content and services." It says nothing about unlawful content. If blocking lawful content is illegal, but not-blocking unlawful content is not illegal, obviously ISPs will err on the side of not blocking grey-area content. It will only be obviously unlawful content that is blocked, which is really no different than today's situation.
- Spooky23 12y agoThe other key fallacy that the telecoms seed the media with is that with common carriage, there is no way to provide quality service. Net neutrality doesn't mean that you cannot optimize the path to get somewhere, just that you don't discriminate. If you need a lower latency or need to lower utilization on certain links, the ISP can do things like peer with the chatty networks.