3 ms·
This reminds me of something I'm curious about: why aren't large SRAM arrays displaying DRAM? I know 6Ts are larger than 1T+1C, but even if SRAM were 6x as expe
by jjoonathan 12y ago
This reminds me of something I'm curious about: why aren't large SRAM arrays displaying DRAM? I know 6Ts are larger than 1T+1C, but even if SRAM were 6x as expensive (which ought to be a severe upper bound) that would put it at $50/GB which sounds like it could easily be worthwhile for certain workloads -- not unlike SSDs a few years ago. The latency advantage would be gigantic, especially if you could crowd the chips near the CPU.
Is SRAM comparatively power hungry or something?
- vardump 12y agoI think SRAM cost is more like $1500/GB.
- jjoonathan 12y agoAre you familiar with an immensely super-linear cost scaling in the # of transistors vs DRAM or are you quoting a cost figure for putting SRAM on the CPU die? If you put DRAM on the CPU die I would also expect it to cost hundreds per GB, but that's not a very interesting comparison because we know from current DRAM best practices that you can put it on its own die at a much lower cost.
- wmf 12y agoRLDRAM exists, so SRAM would have to beat that. In your 6x upper bound maybe you're not taking into account (dis)economies of scale that could cause SRAM to be much more expensive.
- jjoonathan 12y agoWhat diseconomies of scale do you mean? If you mean that demand is low right now and so there is no economy of scale yet, that's hardly evidence against a gradual market takeover. That's what investors and early adopters are for, see: SSDs. If you really do mean diseconomy of scale, where unit price will rise with the number of units produced, what would produce such an effect in the SRAM market? Chip fab is almost always in the opposite regime, what's so unique about SRAM? Also, I looked up RLDRAM [1] and it looks like their "low" latencies are still 10ns, which is good for DRAM but abysmal in comparison to SRAM. [1] http://www.micron.com/products/dram/rldram-memory/1_15Gb#/ http://www.micron.com/products/dram/rldram-memory/1_15Gb#/