11 ms·
I think the thing that would make perl 6 really successful would be to call it something other than perl. Many people who have programmed perl for a long time s
by ChuckMcM 12y ago
I think the thing that would make perl 6 really successful would be to call it something other than perl. Many people who have programmed perl for a long time seem to think it is an abomination of the first order, many people who have never programmed in perl think perl is some sort of dead language like COBOL or PL/1. Both groups are going to have a systemic aversion to this new language simply based on its name. And that is unfortunate.
There are neat things in this new language and there is no reason to leave the sea anchor of a name attached to it. Call it something fresh and new and it can be the cool hotness that is up and coming.
- wwweston 12y agoI think Larry Wall once suggested it converge on perl 2π (progressively approaching 6.2831853071). Not sure about the marketing value, but it's properly geeky.
- steveklabnik 12y agoVery similar to what Knuth did with Tex. I like it.
- JadeNB 12y agoActually, I think that, for exactly that reason, it's a wrong idea. Knuth's numbering is meant to suggest that, except for minor corrections, TeX is in its final form. I can't imagine Larry Wall ever feeling that way about Perl.
- steveklabnik 12y agoAt his FOSDEM talk, he actually talked a little about how Perl 6 should be flexible enough to keep on changing basically forever... given that you can edit the parser even on the fly, it seems plausible.
- chrstphrhrt 12y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4rA4ZRErflE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4rA4ZRErflE Is that what P6 feels like?
- fidotron 12y agoI don't think so. The real problem with Perl is it's an aesthetic train wreck. It is possible to write beautiful Python, Ruby, Erlang, ML, Prolog, C, C++ or even Java, but I challenge anyone to write a non-trivial Perl (5 or 6) program that doesn't make you feel slightly ill. Some of the semantics seem really nice, but the syntax is utterly disastrous.
- nickysielicki 12y agoI disagree, I mostly write perl for my job and I think that most of what I write is at least equally beautiful but generally more beautiful than equivalent python.
- anom9999 12y agoI hear this argument time and time again and it's simply FUD. Bad Perl is no different to bad C++ or any other language with a flexible syntax. But it's also the same visa versa. The problem with Perl is most times people are exposed to it, it's either from code golfing sessions were code is deliberately obfuscated; or when it's basically been used as a shell scripting language and thus often written by aging Perl hackers who don't care much for code cleanliness. And sometimes people just run away screaming because they simply don't understand all the regular expressions (but to approach Perl without an understanding of Regex is a little like trying to code Java without understanding classes then moaning about the weird surplus boilerplate code) I'm not trying to say that Perl doesn't have it's faults. It has a great many problems. But to state that Perls syntax makes it impossible to write clean code, is just a daft flamewar argument.
- nkurz 12y agoI have great fondness for Perl, think the the innovations present in P6 are great, and even I agree with you whole-heartedly: continuing to call it "Perl 6" is a terrible strategic blunder. The redeeming factor is that a great name is already in common use: just officially rename it to "P6". It carries practically no stigma while acknowledging the legacy.
- chrstphrhrt 12y agoP6!
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- lumpypua 12y agoP6 is a sick as fuck name. They need to do this.
- kagamine 12y agoWhy not Perl 2000? It's both futuristic and original. I don't think the name is the problem, I think that there is just too much competition among languages. If you ask a younger person which language they want to learn, will they think of Perl at all? Where is it used? Everywhere isn't an answer, Web or application programming or Apps are answers. What can I use instead that recruiters think is cool/relevant is also a fair question, albeit a simultaneously stupid one.
- lumpypua 12y agoMaybe I'm missing sarcasm. Perl 2000 is the definition of out of touch. 2000 was fifteen years ago.
- davidgerard 12y ago2000 was when the Perl 6 effort started.
- henpa 12y ago
- brudgers 12y agoIt's been so long that Perl is just a language most people might have heard about but probably never used. The name isn't a marketing issue. Perl may even have some of that Lispy retro-mystery.
- cwyers 12y agoThe avalanche has already begun, it is too late for the pebbles to vote. Everyone knows it as Perl 6. Therefore, everyone who would write about it after this proposed name change would say "formerly known as Perl 6," so that people know what you're talking about. All the conceptual baggage remains. (And the reason the Perl name is a boat anchor is because someone hooked a chain to it and sank it to the bottom of the ocean. Perl didn't die from natural causes, Perl was killed by neglect - neglect caused because Perl 6 was always right around the corner and why sink more effort into maintaining Perl 5 than was absolutely necessary? So now OG Perl is stuck on 5.x from now until the heat death of the universe, because this project poisoned the well.)
- machinshin_ 12y ago> The avalanche has already begun, it is too late for the pebbles to vote. thanks for the deep words, Kosh
- desdiv 12y agoI apologize for being out of the loop, but who's Kosh?
- Poiesis 12y agoI don't know what the right answer is here, but I find it intriguing that this approach is in a way the opposite of what Python ended up doing with the 2/3 split.
- kamaal 12y agoThat's not exactly true. While its true that there issues with Perl. Its still by and large a language widely used by developers across the world. There is a also a huge and a very active community which does amazing things with it. Now taking away the name means re doing some 2.5 decades of marketing all over again. No body needs to go over that all over again. There is a set of programmers with whom this won't go down well. Enterprise programmers and the hipsters.
- singingfish 12y agodon't forget the hipster enterprise programmers (aka the contractors)
- peterwwillis 12y agohow are contractors the hipsters of enterprises? if anything they're the yuppies. do whatever the fuck they want, get paid boatloads of cash, don't produce anything of value, are generally dicks. i think you're thinking of brooklyn trustfund hipsters, which are just the new yuppies.
- Ovid 12y agoI'm a consultant, produce plenty of value, have very happy customers, and I don't get called a "dick" too often. Don't pay all of us with the same brush, please :) (Note: I'm the guy who wrote the post OP linked to)
- singingfish 12y agoUs perl contractors (former in my case, a decent job in my home town with good working conditions came up) are what the enterprise turn to when they need to circumvent the bureaucracy.
- erikb 12y agoI'm certainly one who would rather learn Go or Ruby instead of Perl. Because I already know quite a lot Python and a little PHP, AWK and Bash I don't think I'll ever run into a usecase where learning Perl would be worth more than implementing a solution in e.g. Bash+Python+AWK. Around me the people all know these three languages better than Perl (or at least think so). Giving Perl6 a new name would certainly help in making it more interesting.
- riffraff 12y ago> I don't think I'll ever run into a usecase where learning Perl would be worth more than implementing a solution in e.g. Bash+Python+AWK. that might be also because you are not familiar with perl6 though, a form of blub paradox. I.e. are perl6 grammars better for parsing than anything available for python? Maybe or maybe not, but one needs to know them before being able to judge.
- erikb 12y agoThe reason I've written that comment is that I believe Perl lovers can, based on feedback like that, make better decisions about how to present their favourite language to the world. So if I would read a few articles on HN about how problems got solved with Perl in a way that Python wouldn't be able to, then I might start learning Perl soon. That's why I wrote that comment. Not for you guys to feel bad about your favourite language, but about helping you to present it better to people who don't know it yet. The strong features of Perl that I know (which might be completely wrong): Regex and huge library. Both features are not distinct to Perl anymore though. Perl's regex might be a little better than Python's or AWK's but probably not enough to make it worth learning it. And yes learning a new language to level that you not just know the syntax but also a few of the important libraries, blogs and developers is a huge task that takes several months. If you are not a student any more you really need to think hard before you commit to something like that. Sure there are people who just learn new languages for fun as a hobby. But that's not your target audience if you want your favourite language to become more popular.
- 12y ago
- maxlybbert 12y agoThe funny thing (to me) is that a little while ago, the Perl 5 developers started talking about renaming Perl 5 as a branding issue ( http://blogs.perl.org/users/matt_s_trout_mst/2013/02/pumpkin-perl-breakdown.html http://blogs.perl.org/users/matt_s_trout_mst/2013/02/pumpkin... ). Because, obviously, if people don't like what you made, it's just a question of what you called it.