3 ms·
Someone remind me why this isn't in our hard drives yet.
by ikeboy 12y ago
Someone remind me why this isn't in our hard drives yet.
- cek 12y agoBecause it's slow.
- ikeboy 12y agoHow slow? And why can't it be used for archiving purposes or something that doesn't need high-speed access?
- RIMR 12y agoBecause this is a discovery, not an invention. If they could make high-performance biological storage devices the size of hard drives, you don't think they would be doing this already? This probably required a machine significantly larger than most desktop computers, with a pricetag in the $100,000+ range. That and it has a R/W speed of ~30Kb/s... It will be in our hard drives when the technology has been developed to make that happen. I mean, graphene is already looking to be a far more efficient and powerful alternative to silicon. Why isn't that in our processors yet? It's because creating a logic gate and creating an x86 CPU are entirely different things. The same way that encoding a bunch of data into DNA and replicating it a few billion times is entirely different from making an on-demand biological data storage device.
- ikeboy 12y agoThank you. Although, it doesn't make sense that they copied 700 TBs if the speed is 30kb/s. Any idea on how long this will take to get to market, and whether it's being worked on?
- ctdonath 12y agoSame reason we don't heat our homes with nuclear weapons. More capacity than we need by orders of magnitude of orders of magnitude, but rather hard to extract & manage just what you want.
- ikeboy 12y agoI've got a 1.5tb hard drive that's full. I could easily use up 10tb, and probably more over the years. Storage companies buy by the petabyte. The argument that we don't need more storage doesn't work.
- ctdonath 12y agoI didn't say we don't need more storage. I said that all-you'll-ever-need capacity is meaningless if you can't get what little you need without extreme efforts. It's a "drinking from a firehose" problem.
- skosuri 12y agoridiculously expensive, slow, not random access, not re-writable.