10 ms·
I Visit Libraries to Sell Bitcoins to Random People from the Internet
- Shinkei 12y agoSo can anyone explain why banks would suddenly close an account like that in the UK? Would they do that in the US? He is despositing a lot of cash and electronically transmitting money from that account. Wouldn't any small business that does a lot of cash transactions run into this same problem?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- pdeuchler 12y agoHe is despositing a lot of cash and electronically transmitting money from that account. I think that's your answer right there. Small businesses usually have personal connections with their bank and can easily dispel any suspicions of money laundering as well.
- bobbles 12y agoThey would have a small business account with the bank instead of a personal account I'd say.
- jfoster 12y agoGood point. His transactions indicate business-like activity. His account is personal.
- WillNotDownvote 12y agoIt happens with US accounts too. Banks have a strong incentive to avoid money laundering activities, and no real penalty for false positives.
- r00fus 12y agoExcept of course, when they profit handsomely from money laundering [1]... maybe you just need a bigger balance in the account? [1] http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2013-07-02/hsbc-judge-approves-1-9b-drug-money-laundering-accord http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2013-07-02/hsbc-judge...
- engendered 12y agoBanks have a strong incentive to avoid money laundering activities Most banks have automated systems that flag on certain automated conditions (I know because I built one). Contrary to some of the posts in here, they do not want to flag accounts, and most do the absolutely minimal mandated under AML legislation. We have no idea why his account was closed, but it is extremely unlikely it was due to suspected money laundering. If they suspect money laundering, they legally must report it (this is the case in the US, Canada, and the UK, at a minimum) to the appropriate government agency, where it will be investigated. They can't simply say "looks like money laundering, go somewhere else". As always everyone is operating under very incomplete information.
- desdiv 12y agoWe have no idea why his account was closed, but it is extremely unlikely it was due to suspected money laundering. If they suspect money laundering, they legally must report it (this is the case in the US, Canada, and the UK, at a minimum) to the appropriate government agency, where it will be investigated. They can't simply say "looks like money laundering, go somewhere else". "Fill out AML suspicious activities report" and "close his account" are mutually exclusive courses of actions. Just because one happened doesn't mean the other ones didn't happen. Like you said, we're operating under very incomplete information, so let's not assume "fill out AML suspicious activities report" didn't happen here.
- engendered 12y agoThey usually are mutually exclusive, at least in the US and Canada. If an AML flag is triggered, or there is reasonable suspicion, they have to report it and are barred from telling you that you've been reported. Kick you out as a customer would be a great way to undermine the whole AML thing. It is entirely possible that if he simply had transfers to or from known Bitcoin entities, that would have triggered it. Not because he did anything illegal -- Bitcoin isn't currently illegal in most places, and they have zero onus to report anything in that case -- but that the bank is hedging that there will be issues that come up in the future and they don't want the hassle. That they have determined that Bitcoin is going to be a regulation hassle in the future so they simply want to have nothing to do with it. This is in no way money laundering, or suspicion of it, and they needn't report anything -- just tell him to get lost so in a year or two when this becomes a big thing they have limited their exposure.
- petercooper 12y agoBanks can choose who they do business with and at least in the UK they're known for closing accounts for reasonably arbitrary or accidental reasons. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-15794539 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-15794539 http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programmes/moneybox/9637740.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programmes/moneybox/9637740.stm http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-18540832 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-18540832 At least in this case, it wasn't a freezing of assets, more a "we're not the right bank for you, go away".
- patio11 12y agoNo, because a small business that does a lot of cash transactions would, on review of the account, look like a business, not like a money transmitter. There would be checks written to vendors, withdraws from a payroll company corresponding to a predictable cycle, probably a rent check on a predictable cycle, etc. If your only two transactions are "Deposit lots of cash" and "transfer it to another bank" the bank will come to the conclusion "To the extent that there is a business here, it is probably money laundering." The bank was right.
- code_duck 12y agoThese transactions would be half money laundering only if the buyers only came from illegal activities and they were avoiding deposit in a typical bank. It's not laundering by the author as he is not involved or aware of the buyers' money's providence. I don't see how it would be money laundering more than say, buying $3000 of gold from a local gold and silver shop. I'm hardly an expert in... Anything, though. If you care to explain that would be lovely.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoMost of legitimate financial activity forms follow well known patterns. Illegal activities often follow different patterns. It's reasonable for a bank to flag suspicious accounts, even though you'll always have some false positives - because if it looks like money laundering, most of the time it is. Also I don't know if this works with banks (having no personal experience here), but I remember back from the time when early Kickstarter projects got their PayPal accounts frozen, that the rule of thumb was: if you're going to do something on your PayPal account that looks weird/atypical, it's a good idea to call them in advance and tell them about that.
- code_duck 12y agoI agree it may look like money laundering. But one can't really say "the bank was right" in this case since it wasn't money laundering.
- Spooky23 12y agoBanks have an obligation to report suspicious activity, and many will cut you off if they see a pattern or trend that could be suspicious to reduce risk. The governor of New York's prostitution habit was discovered a few years ago when a bank risk guy flagged money transfers from his account.
- Potando 12y ago"nothing could be done over the phone, though I was welcome to walk into a branch and try my luck there" - This is sadly common with UK banks. They want you to go to the branch for all sorts of things that really don't need it, but the branch is always closed or overcrowded when you have time to get there. It doesn't help that you have to use your own branch, not any of the others - as if they don't have a computer network between them? Or perhaps they feel the local staff somehow remember who you are and what your tedious banking problems are? Somehow they decide there's no need to be open in the morning, evening or Saturday afternoons, even though they're turning people away and squeezing the bloated queue inside the doors so they can get ready to close. I was also overseas when I was told the only way to get the few thousand pounds from my account was to go the the branch. Eventually they found another way.
- ojm 12y agoSame thing in Australia. Have to visit the branch for simple tasks that should be doable over the phone. Plus the branches are often busy and close early. I recently got married and my wife changed her surname to my surname. The process of updating this was quite a pain for most Australian banks (even when she was just an additional card holder on a credit card). However, for American Express card, this process was extremely easy. Phone up, customer service emails, reply back with a copy of marriage certificate, new card in the mail within a few days. Perhaps not 100% secure, but easy. Perhaps they take more processes from the US?
- adnrw 12y agoInteresting - what trouble did you have with the banks here? I am a NAB customer and when we got married it was one form to fill in (with associated documentation) to update my wife's details across all of the accounts, including having new debit/credit cards sent out by post within the week.
- eru 12y agoIn Australia, just use ING Direct. They do banking right. (The ING Group also operates in other countries. In Germany they are called DKB.)
- devindotcom 12y agoHow interesting. Makes me want to set up a similar service where I am. $500 minimum, mark it up a steady 10% based on price when the order is placed, and offer to buy the coffee when you meet at the local cafe to make the swap. Hard to make a living unless you're doing it full time, but the hobby would pay for itself and then some, and you'd meet some interesting people and learn your way around the ecosystem. As for the money... keep the cash! Use the cash! Cash is convenient, cash is universal! I've been thinking about going all cash for anything but purchases that must be made online, and even those can be made with prepay cards that can be bought with cash. edit: a moment of thought reveals you have to put the cash back into the system somehow or another in order to fund more bitcoins. So, there's that fantasy shot.
- stavrianos 12y agoIf nothing else, you can feed the cash into transactions that would otherwise not have been. All your groceries are now paid with bitcoin cash, and the difference can be applied to buying more bitcoins. There's a ceiling there, but unless business is booming, I bet you never hit it.
- stirlo 12y agoThe article talks about transactions for $3000, that is a lot of cash to spend on groceries.
- wingerlang 12y agoAlthough a $3000 transaction would, for the author, be ~$300.
- glomph 12y agoYeah but you still have $3000 in cash.
- flatline 12y agoAnother thing to shoot down that fantasy: someone makes a casual mention of illegal activity, and as soon as you complete the transaction they pull out their FBI badge and arrest you on charges of money laundering, aiding a criminal, etc. People from localbitcoins have been targeted and subsequently busted this way, for doing no more than this guy.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Buge 12y agoCounterfeit money is a bit risk when doing this. There have been several stories of localbitcoin sellers receiving counterfeit money.
- dmix 12y agoSame with any cash business. If you don't have volume or capital as a risk mitigation you shouldn't be engaged in it.
- driverdan 12y agoAssuming you mean big risk, how so? It's very hard to counterfeit modern currency. Color changing ink, watermarks, and the embedded strip are all hard to counterfeit especially in tandem.
- joosters 12y agoYou don't need to be the counterfeiter. Unskilled fraudsters could buy the counterfeit money (perhaps on the dark net, with Bitcoin!)
- glomph 12y agoSure but your average bitcoin trader doesn't have the equipment to pick up on those features.
- logn 12y agoWith US bills, you can use one of these... costs $5.50: http://www.officedepot.com/a/products/548370/Dri-Mark-US-Counterfeit-Money-Detector/ http://www.officedepot.com/a/products/548370/Dri-Mark-US-Cou... Also, on $100 bills, Ben Franklin has a ghost image that can be seen holding up to the light.
- droopyEyelids 12y agoThe best way to test is with a strong neodymium magnet. Magnetic ink is one of the last frontiers that counterfeiters have yet to break. But better than all of that is to require the transaction to happen in a branch of your local bank, or post office, and be funded by a money order from the bank or post office.
- legulere 12y ago> I knew I was playing in a grey area For me it looks like this is obviously illegal because he conducts a business without registering one.
- devindotcom 12y agoIf you bake pies at home and sell them to friends, do you have to register yourself as a business? There might be benefits to it but he could also just be self-employed. As long as he declares his earnings and pays taxes on them there shouldn't be a problem.
- dragonwriter 12y agoIf it is strictly "to friends" in a way that is not legally to the general public, possibly not (but if you are soliciting people in public places, then its probably public sales.) For public sales of food, you probably need both a business license and separate health clearance for selling food, if your state law even allows selling food made in a home kitchen (California recently adopted a law allowing this, with very narrow limits.)
- darkFunction 12y agoYou can make a certain amount of capital gains in the UK without paying tax. It's in the region of 10K I think. I guess buying bitcoin at market price and selling at 'a different market price' counts as capital gains on an investment until the point where you've made enough money to have to declare it. And this would be on your tax form at the end of the year. At least that's how I understand it. I'm not an accountant but have been unloading a few coins this year and I'm pretty sure I don't need to declare anything until I make more than a certain amount across all my investments. https://www.gov.uk/personal-tax/capital-gains-tax https://www.gov.uk/personal-tax/capital-gains-tax
- Chirael 12y agoIn the US, as I understand it you wouldn't be able to use capital gains on this kind of thing because you haven't held the Bitcoins for a year. It would be "short term capital gain" which would be the same as ordinary income. The real risk here is that if you don't track all the transactions and report and pay taxes on the profit (at, likely, ordinary income tax rates), you'll get nailed for tax evasion. I imagine (though I have no experience) that this must be similar to having a marijuana based business. If you want to be legit you have to open a bank account... but not a lot of banks want to touch a business like that. You might think you could just lie on the bank account opening form where it asks about what the business will be doing, and say you're opening a coffee shop or food cart (something with cash sales), but then you could be nailed for lying on a form, and since (again in the US) most accounts are FDIC insured, that could be under the rubric of lying to the Federal government (not good). I don't have direct experience with this, IANAL etc., but these are some loose concepts that come to mind. Too bad, great idea, classic good example of arbitrage/exploiting market inefficiencies. I think it's even do-able legitimately, though it's slightly too far along the risk-reward curve for my taste ATM.
- freedombeer 12y agoWhat gives? This is just a promo ad for money laundering.
- edward 12y agoBitcoin article on the Barclays website: https://wealth.barclays.com/en_gb/home/research/research-centre/compass/compass-apr-2014/evolution-of-modern-money.html https://wealth.barclays.com/en_gb/home/research/research-cen...
- joosters 12y agoI don't get it: They say that they started using Bitcoin to help transfer money overseas, yet later in the article they talk of using TransferWise to move money abroad (which deals in pounds and dollars, not Bitcoin) If bitcoin's strength is meant to be its low cost for moving money around, how come even this Bitcoin peddlar cashes out back into fiat to move it?
- pjc50 12y agoHe's running an arbitrage cycle, selling bitcoins for pounds. In order to get bitcoins he's buying them on an exchange with dollars.
- timdierks 12y agoI am not a lawyer, but the author should consult one. Money transmitting businesses are heavily regulated in the United States, and operating such a business without registration and compliance with regulations may be illegal. These laws are not a joke; there's a reason that all the mainstream Bitcoin businesses have these constraints, registrations, and rules, despite the way they impede customers and businesses: "know your customer", anti-money laundering and Patriot act constraints on terrorism funding are very real and serious interests of government units with powerful enforcement powers. Be warned that this is not the same as selling lemonade in the government's eyes.
- supercanuck 12y agofurthermore, that markup is probably classified as unreported income. One more thing to nail the author on.
- dougddo 12y agoIAAL. I'll cover money laundering first since it seems to get so often repeated here: No, exchanging bitcoin for cash, or vice versa, is not in and of itself money laundering. Replace "bitcoin" with "casino chips". Is every casino in Vegas behind bars? No. Why not? Because there was no intent to launder, only an intent to exchange value for value. Secondly, the concern over bitcoin dealing being a Money Services Business (MSB) is a little more legitimate. IIRC, FinCEN has already stated that these sorts of businesses are MSBs, and require all the usual compliance measures attached to that label. There are also some states that consider bitcoin trading businesses MSBs as well, on the state level. On a practical level though, hardly anyone is enforcing these rules. Does that mean there's no risk? No, of course not; there's definitely a risk. It's just not currently that large of a risk. Lastly, with regards to unreported income, that's an issue with any income, regardless of source. If a stranger handed you $10 out of nowhere, that's income and you're required to report it. Hell, if you sold some crack to that stranger in exchange for those $10, you're required to report it. Unreported income is not a bitcoin specific concern.
- timdierks 12y agoI didn't mean it was necessarily laundering, just that there's a number of regulations intended to detect and control money laundering that may apply to the author.