4 ms·
> if Wheeler says thats how it is, then that's how it is Not entirely. It's a proposal, which must be voted on by the rest of the FCC committee. It's unlikely
by Alupis 12y ago
> if Wheeler says thats how it is, then that's how it is
Not entirely. It's a proposal, which must be voted on by the rest of the FCC committee. It's unlikely everyone on the committee will agree 100%, but I'd also contend it's unlikely for this to not pass in and around it's current state.
- niels_olson 12y agoAnyone care to bet the cable companies will take a no-holds-barred attempt to delay this until after the presidential election?
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Anyone care to bet the cable companies will take a no-holds-barred attempt to delay this until after the presidential election? They'll probably just sue to invalidate it once the FCC finalizes it (they may seek a preliminary injunction preventing enforcement as part of that, as well); there isn't much they can do in the way of delaying it otherwise.
- kevin_thibedeau 12y agoHe got a 3/2 split on the redefinition of broadband with one of the yeas publicly admitting that she would have rather seen 100Mbit as the threshold. It stands to reason that this will pass too with the current committee makeup. If the GOP wins 2016, however, the future may not be so bright once they install their pro-business people and fix all of this "Socialist" claptrap.
- wooter 12y agoGood. Why people want the government's hand's deeper in the internet than now is beyond me. Look at mobile data (exempt from title II) versus "broadband"/cable speeds. Wheeler actually points to the success of title II on "mobile" while ignoring the fact that it only applied to voice. Meanwhile, all the relevant growth and innovation occurred in data. I have to say I'ld like to see the "socialist claptrap", feel-good crap, out of here. Lastly, who thinks the people have a leg to stand on versus the NSA and privacy if the government has more control over the internet? http://reason.com/blog/2015/02/04/the-bad-argument-behind-the-fccs-move-to http://reason.com/blog/2015/02/04/the-bad-argument-behind-th...
- tormeh 12y ago>Wheeler actually points to the success of title II on "mobile" while ignoring the fact that it only applied to voice. Meanwhile, all the relevant growth and innovation occurred in data. Only voice and SMS mattered until 2007(iPhone launch). Title II seemed to work pretty well until then. >Look at mobile data (exempt from title II) versus "broadband"/cable speeds. The difference in infrastructure costs makes those two incomparable. Look, you just suffer under a reality distortion field.
- wooter 12y ago> Only voice and SMS mattered until 2007(iPhone launch). So the areas in which regulated are the ones which stagnated and became dramatically less relevant? It seems to me like you're suffering the distortion field.
- tormeh 12y agoAre you trolling? Data is to voice as electricity is to fire; one is inherently more versatile and can handle all applications the other can. You're basically asking the equivalent of "why has all the innovation happened in electricity and not in fire? Must be the gubmint's fault" What did you expect? That a robot would read out websites to us?
- whyaduck 12y agoWireless carriers compete directly with one another on price and performance regardless of geo. There's no local monopoly. Huge difference.
- Amezarak 12y ago> Wheeler actually points to the success of title II on "mobile" while ignoring the fact that it only applied to voice. Meanwhile, all the relevant growth and innovation occurred in data. Innovation like single-gig data caps? Or do you mean innovation like "unlimited data, except no streaming and no hotspots"? Compared to the voice situation on mobile, or to landline Internet, mobile Internet is garbage. I don't understand what you mean. Heck, IME, 50mbps landline Internet is easier to get than 4G Internet is outside of cities. And the price isn't much better either. I pay $50/mo for 50mbps down for cable Internet, I pay $40/mo for my 2GB capped Verizon Internet which is 4G (sometimes).
- Alupis 12y ago> If the GOP wins 2016, however, the future may not be so bright Can we please stop trying to make this a "GOP is evil and hates America" and "DEM is right and loves America" thing? The GOP standpoint is to put policy in place that naturally overtime encourages small business to bring competition to the bigger guys. The problem with this plan is it takes time and people want an immediate result. That's not "hating america" and it's not "doomsday" if GOP wins in 2016. Nor is the President a king -- ie. the President has Zero control over what the FCC does. So it really doesn't matter who wins in 2016 since you already have a strongly led GOP congress... who does have power over the FCC.
- wwweston 12y ago> Can we please stop trying to make this a "GOP is evil and hates America" and "DEM is right and loves America" thing? Whether or not the GOP is generally evil, it certainly seems to be true that their position on net neutrality has been consistently bad and if they're allowed set policy on it, they'll do it in a way that will let carriers interpose themselves as gatekeepers. >The GOP standpoint is to put policy in place that naturally overtime encourages small business to bring competition to the bigger guys. That's the rhetoric, anyway. It's less clear how that's likely to fall out of any of their proposed policies.
- Alupis 12y agoThe point is neither the GOP nor the DEM get to decide what net neutrality policy is... that is the FCC's job now that congress has given them that power. This isn't a party thing... let's not try to make it one.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> The point is neither the GOP nor the DEM get to decide what net neutrality policy is... that is the FCC's job The members of the FCC are Democratic and Republican political appointees. > This isn't a party thing... Every FCC vote on Open Internet ("net neutrality") rules for the last several years has had a 3-2 divide on party lines (Democrats for Open Internet regs, Republicans against). How is it not a party thing?