3 ms·
The main concern people seem to have is the site's use of CloudFlare, a content delivery tool company that can protect sites from DDoS attacks and help manage a
by jgrahamc 12y ago
The main concern people seem to have is the site's use of CloudFlare, a content delivery tool company that can protect sites from DDoS attacks and help manage a large influx of traffic.
To do this, it grabs IP addresses (a number assigned to each internet-connected device by its internet service provider that can often be used to identify a person), which conspiracy-minded folks say would be a nice thing for the FBI to have. Theoretically, if CloudFlare is saving these IP addresses, the FBI could subpoena CloudFlare for that data. And if the government is actually running the site, then it would have those IP addresses by default.
This is a very confusing argument. If the FBI controls The Pirate Bay then it wouldn't need CloudFlare to be able to get the IP addresses of people connecting to The Pirate Bay because... they'd be The Pirate Bay and so would see people connecting.
- sarciszewski 12y agoI think a more convincing argument is that they're relying on CloudFlare to hide the IP address of the server, which is probably not very covert. http://www.wired.com/2013/08/freedom-hosting/ http://www.wired.com/2013/08/freedom-hosting/ "It just sends identifying information to some IP in Reston, Virginia." If the FBI does nothing else, they learn from past mistakes.
- eli 12y agoWouldn't a non-FBI owner of Pirate Bay also want to obscure the IP of the server just as much? I don't really follow this argument.
- sarciszewski 12y ago> Wouldn't a non-FBI owner of Pirate Bay also want to obscure the IP of the server just as much? Yep. > I don't really follow this argument. It's not a piece of evidence in favor of the FBI being involved. It's an explanation for why they would use CloudFlare and/or what they would use CF for. As I said elsewhere, I don't really buy the arguments. But I don't use TPB either. The only torrent I download are Linux/BSD ISOs. So I'm not going to risk my freedom on not buying arguments. :)
- nickik 12y agoThe IP is also not enougth, you need to prove that these people actually downloaded files and that still happens peer to peer, right?
- nissehulth 12y agoThey could be more interested in people uploading stuff, aka posting new torrents. That's done on-site.