3 ms·
I wonder why we use the term "terrorism", as opposed to paramilitary organization, which I think is a more relevant construct. Terrorism defines a group based o
by threatofrain 12y ago
I wonder why we use the term "terrorism", as opposed to paramilitary organization, which I think is a more relevant construct. Terrorism defines a group based on its methods which are supposed to deliver fear or some kind of mass hysteria to the public.
A paramilitary organization may or may not use tactics of terror, and even if they do, their tactics may be a small part of why they are harmful and relevant.
Under this construct, we can talk about cartels, IS/ISIL, Al Qaeda, IRA, and so on.
And you know how in every large forum, when someone talks about the definition of terrorism, inevitably states also get pulled into the discussion, such as the actions of the US / Russia / China? That's because terrorism is an over-inclusive lens of discussion or perception, which means it requires "discretion" to use the term. It genuinely is wishy-washy.
- tptacek 12y agoMost domestic terrorist groups the FBI tracks don't really fit the definition of "paramilitary organizations". Terrorism describes the strategy of pinpoint deployment of outlandish violence to coerce policy by generating fear. That's one strategy used by paramilitary organizations, but so is "seize and hold territory" or "persistently disrupt supply lines". Islamist terrorists don't target JFK airport in the hopes of disrupting our military supply lines. They do it to provoke the US public by creating fear. Having said that: I'm not sure what coherent public policy objective is served by singling out "terrorism" from other violent crimes. At the level of law enforcement, criminal violence if criminal violence whether it be in the service of a bank robbery or a radical animal rights protest.
- detcader 12y agoYou hold that Islamist terrorists must necessarily have the (vaguely defined by you) motive of "provoking the US", when most Islamist attackers on the U.S. have consistently cited a particular political motive? [1] And yes, it would have been great if the U.S. government had treated "terrorism" as the law enforcement issue it is rather than starting convenient[2] wars. I recommend President of the CCR Michael Ratner's 2004 book "Guantanamo: What the World Should Know" for early treatment of the things being discussed in the comments here. [1] http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2013/apr/24/boston-terrorism-motives-us-violence http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2013/apr/24/boston-... [2] http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2013/mar/18/david-frum-iraq-war-oil http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2013/mar/18/david-f...
- threatofrain 12y agoBut I think it's actually a good thing that some domestic terrorist groups don't fit the definition of paramilitary organization. To make our construct useful in public policy, we should be able to propose broad treatment across all members of a construct and be able to predict consistent outcome. We should be interested in developing useful tools for policy talk, and being able to make grounded generalizations is super useful. I don't think the Unabomber or Anonymous fits in the same policy discussion as IS or Al Qaeda, because I think these problems suggest very divergent courses of policy. Every time we have to make caveats to our category, every time we must exercise discretion in interpretation, we will find our construct proportionally less robust. Imagine a government rule which authorizes military action against IS, cartels, or Al Qaeda, including assassinations and characterized by an absence of legal process. Whether or not I agree with this rule, I can accept that it is sensible and potentially productive to at least talk about. I can accept that these groups have common characteristics which behave consistently following military or civilian interventions, thus permitting policy generalizations. I can also see that there is an intuitive connection between the solution and the problem. What is hard to accept is that Unabomber and Anonymous should be on that same table for discussion, because what the overinclusion of these groups do is move the line of justification to remove legal process a little closer to home, and a little more into the realm of capricious discretion. It's hard to accept that some domestic terrorists are anything like an organization that has revenue streams, human resource management, infrastructure, administration, a paramilitary force, and so on, and so it's hard to connect the solution to the problem. Of course, behind all of this is the assumption that terrorist organizations are so mighty that they have graduated beyond the class of criminal and into sub-state actor, and that ordinary civilian instruments are totally inadequate, and that military solutions are the only effective solutions.
- desdiv 12y agoBecause "paramilitary" has a strict legal definition[0] in addition the commonly used informal definition of "organized armed group that's not a government sanctioned military power". The California State Military Reserve[1], for example, is a paramilitary organization under that legal definition. About two dozen states have similar paramilitary state defense forces[2], all of which are distinct from both federal military units and the state's own National Guard units. [0] https://www.icrc.org/customary-ihl/eng/docs/v1_rul_rule4 https://www.icrc.org/customary-ihl/eng/docs/v1_rul_rule4 [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_State_Military_Reserve http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_State_Military_Reser... [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_defense_force http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_defense_force