7 ms·
I understand lots of people will want to paint this as a sweeping indictment of minimum wage hikes overall but all of us here should know better than to general
by munificent 12y ago
I understand lots of people will want to paint this as a sweeping indictment of minimum wage hikes overall but all of us here should know better than to generalize from one sample, especially one as skewed as this.
Here, we have a business that:
1. Is in a market that's been declining for decades.
2. Is in one of the most expensive cities in the United States.
3. Has a product with an essentially fixed price.
4. Sells a "commodity" product: the book you get from there is indistiguishable from the same book bought elsewhere. (Of course, the overall book buying experience is unique.)
5. Sells a product that has a digital alternative rapidly rising in popularity.
6. Is in the number #1 city in the entire world for people predisposed to prefer digital alternatives to things.
They may as well have been a cash-only store for horse-drawn carriage accessories. I'm sad they're closing, but it's amazing they lasted as long as they did and says next to nothing about large-scale economic policy.
- hullo 12y agoI know it's only one of the points, but it's not true that ebooks are still "rapidly rising in popularity" - while they do seem to continue to become more popular, the trajectory has clearly slowed. It seems, generally speaking, that we're nearing if not already at a stable rate of ebook market share (on a revenue basis, at least w/r/t the US and UK markets, the only ones I can claim to watch closely.) For point 1, while I don't have the data, I would be very surprised to find out that over the course of "decades" book sales (or even just print book sales) have "declined", especially given the rate of population growth. What has, 100%, happened is that sales have moved online, for the commodity reason you mentioned, and Amazon's inclination to deeply discount titles to gain market share (which they now are moving ever-so-steadily away from).
- lucio 12y agohttp://blogs.reuters.com/great-debate/2009/05/14/thousands-lose-jobs-due-to-higher-federal-minimum-wage/ http://blogs.reuters.com/great-debate/2009/05/14/thousands-l...
- ChuckMcM 12y agoAnd trapped between the commodity supplier fixing the price, and the state bringing up the costs, its a solid recipe for killing off a business. Which it has done in this case. So the more interesting question from an economics perspective is whether or not capturing the marginal GDP of this business is a better or worse for the people. Sure the bookstore goes poof, and folks can't get cheap used books any more. The business will be replaced by something that can afford both the higher labor rate, like an upscale coffee shop or maybe a designer boutique. But the number of bookstores goes down by one, and the volumes available are not available in the library. So the community has lost something too. Nominally the markets are there to express what is a good application of capital by meeting demand. Should it go to running a bookstore or running a coffee roaster or a blog aggregator Etc. But the artificial floor of minimum wage creates artificial barriers to applying capital. You can see in this post that the floor of $10 allows the bookstore to exist, the floor of $15 does not. So here is a fiscal policy which is going limit choices. And a really interesting effect is that everyone is going to raise prices to cover that expense, they have too, and so all of those folks who were complaining that they can't afford to eat at the 'upscale' bars and bistros in California its just going to get worse for them, and it won't be the Googlers or Twitterers or Pinsters causing that upswing, it will be the very government they elected to serve them doing it to them. I find the economics of such things very interesting in the side effects as much as the intended effects.
- niels_olson 12y ago> folks can't get cheap used books any more Perhaps you meant locally? Bookfinder, amazon, alibris, et al still provide excellent service.
- x0x0 12y agoI'd bet all those books are available less expensively on amazon. The only value being lost is the value of the curation by the owners. It's also a function of demand elasticity whether cost increases are passed to consumers, eaten by businesses, or some combination. We'll see how much pricing power local businesses have. And it's a real stretch to argue that a small business owner earning under $30k/year, with limited growth prospects, is an efficient deployment of capital. This was clearly a labor of love.
- KevinEldon 12y agoIt seems that business was go well since the author writes "2014 was the best year we've ever had." But as you point out in a tough market with massive competitors and fixed prices it's hard to absorb a 39% payroll increase. Wish I could look into the future and see what business would replace them in that space... I'm cynically imagining a Starbucks or some ultra-hoppy brew pub.
- acdha 12y agoI read that as more “even our best year was borderline” – further down the page they mention that the general manager was making $28,000/year and the profit in 2013 was roughly $3,000. It's possible for both “best year we've ever had” and ”still not enough to make it work” to be true at the same time.
- eltondegeneres 12y agoDespite all that, their next-door neighbor, Dog Eared Books, had their best year ever in 2014 and that's been true for the past five years. Maybe it's because Borderlands has a narrower focus?
- fencepost 12y agoFirst, Dog Eared Books has a broader audience (Borderlands added mystery at one point, but going beyond that isn't feasible for both space and focus/curation reasons). Second, just because they had their best year ever doesn't mean that it was what an objective observer would call a "good" year. Odds are very high that they're already looking at these same issues and trying to figure out how to get past them, but with different strengths. On the upside for them compared to Borderlands they have a broader base, but on the downside they may not have the same kind of genre-based support. I'll call location a wash, since both are in Mission. On the downside for them, I suspect they don't have as much genre support, in that SF/F readers and authors do often try to support their few remaining genre bookstores. If I want a signed copy of my favorite author's new work, I'm likely either getting it directly from the author, ordering it from Borderlands, Uncle Hugo's (Minneapolis) or DreamHaven Books (Minneapolis, limited hours), or purchasing it from a bookseller at a SF convention because that seller has also been at a convention with those authors. Finally, if you'd told me that a bookstore owner/manager was making less than $30k/year in San Francisco after 15 years in business and with an operating profit of $3000 for the year, I'd have to call that business unsustainable at least in California and particularly anywhere in the Bay Area.
- stickfigure 12y agoThis reinforces the point made by people who oppose the minimum wage. The argument opposing the minimum wage is not that it hurts businesses equally, but that it focuses the pain on businesses and workers at the margins. Here we have a business that for all the reasons you point out is a marginal business, and this price shock pushed it over the edge. It should be somewhat tautologically obvious that the businesses who have the hardest time absorbing a price shock like the minimum wage are the ones that are struggling already. This can be ignored with regard to large-scale industrial policy only if you feel there is no value in marginal industries. But keep in mind that almost all businesses go through "marginal" periods eventually, either on the way up or the way down (or both, sometimes multiple times).
- dangerlibrary 12y agoIf they have a strong argument that they will be able to come back after being marginal, they can take out a loan or seek investment. Otherwise, it's just a matter of delaying the inevitable.
- smsm42 12y agoIt's not inevitable without additional burden of minimum wage increase, it is inevitable with it There's a level of expense where the business is viable, and the level of expense where the business is not viable, and no investment or loans are going to change that - investments/loans are temporary measures, they do not change the income/expense balance. The only way investment could help is if it could either reduce the expenses long-term or increase the income long-term, this was not possible. In that situation, increase of the expense brought by minimum wage rise took the business from the point of being viable to the point of being non-viable, just as any increase of the expenses that can not be avoided would.
- pixl97 12y ago>It's not inevitable without additional burden of minimum wage increase Why not. Inflation doesn't increase on product evenly. If book sales prices do not inflate, but property and fuel costs do expenses increase but profits do not.
- hnnewguy 12y ago>should know better than to generalize from one sample It isn't simply looking at one data point; there are economic fundamentals that demonstrate that this will occur. Just grab any Econ 101 textbook. Granted, it isn't a straight-up loss, as there is some income re-distribution that occurs, putting more money in the pockets of low-wage earners. It's never been clear to me why this is so controversial. If I have organized my business around the fact that I am getting $10.50 worth of production from workers that I pay $10.00, then suddenly I have to pay those same workers $14.00, the math no longer works. Someone will be out of work, or I'll be out of business, period.
- pbh101 12y agoThe implicit assumption as far as I can tell is that you, as "nasty business owner", are making much more than 50 cents of margin on your employees' hourly labor and that minimum wage hikes will make you eat that cost. I haven't looked closely into the studies put forth, but it is repeatedly mentioned that studies show that unemployment (and partial employment) doesn't go up when the minimum wage increases.
- pixl97 12y ago> Someone will be out of work, or I'll be out of business, period. Incorrect, unless you're very inefficient and your competitors are efficient. If you are operating at maximum efficiently, you'll raise your rates to $14.50 and your customers will pay it or go without, no other competitor will be able to sell for less than that without losing money. It's more likely you'll go out of business because your competing businesses allocate their capital more effectively, surviving on smaller profit margins. At worst for the customer they will pay the same effective rate after the wage increase.
- vii 12y agoThis is a deliberate attempt by the owners of the bookstore to make press about the minimum wage causing them to close down. As apparently Alan and Judy are owner operators, doing very little business so hopefully not requiring much external labour, this is a slightly contorted argument. Who would complain that they are not paying themselves the minimum wage and couldn't they structure it so they were not employees of their own partnership? The unfortunate fact is that the owners have so far been able to exploit this location poorly. Valencia St around that block is now very highly sought after with numerous new glitzy businesses opening up in the last few years. If they were lucky enough to own the property or have a transferable lease they would now have an opportunity to make a huge profit on selling it to someone willing to cater to the yuppie crowd. The fact that this is not referred to in the blog post is quite disingenuous. Another bookshop that closed down in SF was much more honest about the reasons without a weird political agenda: http://missionlocal.org/2015/01/a-heaven-for-books-moves-on/ http://missionlocal.org/2015/01/a-heaven-for-books-moves-on/ If one takes a right wing point of view then the fact that the space will now be used more efficiently is definitely beneficial, so if the minimum wage were to blame then must be good ;) From the point of view of the left, the question might be whether the bookstore should be subsidized to provide a living wage to its employees and owners. This is rather difficult to support as it is unclear that there is any benefit accrued to anybody beyond a sort of nostalgic effect of having a rather empty bookshop on a busy street, and if that space should be subsidized it should be made more widely useful.