5 ms·
'Correct' because people favor an irregular usage is a weak form of correct. I favor the effort to try and keep the language regular. Following rules makes it
by JoeAltmaier 12y ago
'Correct' because people favor an irregular usage is a weak form of correct. I favor the effort to try and keep the language regular. Following rules makes it easier to learn and teach.
- tankenmate 12y agoAnd you included my pet grammatical peeve; "try and". And so I favour the effort to try to keep the language regular; various English spellings notwithstanding.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoThank you! I'll try to do better. A preposition makes more sense there. Which preposition could be argued. In New Zealand folks say 'he is different to us' instead of 'he is different from us'. One could imagine 'he is different by us' or 'he is different beside us' as correct somewhere. Hm. Is 'try to keep' using 'to' in a prepositional sense? That's a slippery word.
- pdpi 12y agoPretty sure the 'to' there is a part of an infinitive. Replace it with a gerund and it becomes clear: "Try reading it upside down" vs "Try to read it upside down".
- mathieuh 12y agoI think you should have a read: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Register_(sociolinguistics) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Register_(sociolinguistics)
- Sir_Cmpwn 12y agoSomething that bothers me is the recent (past few hundred years) effort by (English speaking) humans to stop the development of the language. When did it stop being okay for the language to evolve? Isn't part of the beauty of it that it changes, that people use it differently, that words have new meanings?
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoIt may be beautiful, but it isn't very helpful. Imagine if computer language terms changed semantics - all the code that is destroyed. Stopping development isn't a blanket thing. Stopping vandals from painting on the train cars isn't 'stopping the development of rail travel'
- ForHackernews 12y agoEnglish is either already, or rapidly becoming, the lingua franca for the entire world. If we allow to it continue evolving without constraint, we may well wind up with numerous mutually unintelligible dialects. This is already true of many other languages like Chinese and Arabic. It would be a shame if people from India could no longer understand people from Australia, even when they were both using English.
- notahacker 12y agoOn the other hand, a high proportion of the most vigorously-defended aspects of the English language are at best unnecessary to aid understanding, and at worst arcane irregularities which survive as shibboleths to distinguish speakers by their level of education.
- bmelton 12y agoThat assumes that evolution is always good. It isn't. Consider the recent acceptance of the ironic usage of "literally" to mean "figuratively". If it wins, there will no longer be as precise a word that means only "literally", and the English language will have suffered a loss. I am all for the evolution of language where it creates new words, adopts and embraces portmanteaus, or embraces the use of easily intuited non-words into the common parlance, but not every change is an improvement, and where a non-improvement exists, it should be resisted.
- tedunangst 12y agoHave we recently changed the definition of recent? You know how far back literally meaning not literally goes, right?
- spdustin 12y agoRegular is measured by consensus, is it not?