I think we'll just have to disagree on the actual import of rate-limiting. I do agree that competition is very important. What I'll leave it with is this: proh

I think we'll just have to disagree on the actual import of rate-limiting. I do agree that competition is very important. What I'll leave it with is this: prohibiting rate-limiting at best does nothing to increase competition among ISPs (I have not seen any arguments against this), whereas rate-limiting behavior is something I've never seen in a market with multiple viable ISP choices (by which I mean that dialup and satellite are not close enough to broadband to count). As I started this entire thread with, rate-limiting seems like a red herring.