4 ms·
So Uber is using low wage drivers to make money so they can invest in self driving cars to completely make the drivers obsolete. Talk about a moral paradox.
by ThomPete 12y ago
So Uber is using low wage drivers to make money so they can invest in self driving cars to completely make the drivers obsolete.
Talk about a moral paradox.
- akshatpradhan 12y agoI'm ok with that. These drivers will move onto intelligent work where they can get trained in less menial work. The only reason a taxi driver stays a taxi driver is because he believes he has no other alternative to make money. Let's get them training in customer service or creative work and give them human jobs.
- ThomPete 12y agoI am not sure what you mean. For most people this is it.
- Ygg2 12y agoI don't think it will work out that way. If Uber dumps them cold they'll have no money to retrain. Also I doubt taxi driver stays taxi driver because of all alternative opportunities he has.
- akshatpradhan 12y agoWhat were these drivers doing before Uber? Let's not pretend that any job is an ok job. These jobs are not ok for humans and with a basic income, these people can contribute in better more creatives ways. My best friends mom was a cleaner for the Hilton for 20+ years. Sure it was a job, but there was nothing meaningful about it.
- ThomPete 12y agoI am not sure what you are trying to get at. The people who are drivers are drivers for many different reasons some of the are quite well educated and I don't think you can conclude what you seem to conclude. Technology killing jobs is a real problem, technology killing jobs in an increasingly faster and faster pace is an even bigger problem as it doesn't allow people to re-educate themselves. It's a much much much bigger problem than you seem to imply.
- EpicEng 12y ago"These drivers will move onto intelligent work where they can get trained in less menial work" Can you point to any time in history where that actually occurred on a large scale? Genuinely interested.
- jessriedel 12y ago75% of the US used to be farmers. (Not all of farming is menial, but a lot of it is and it was much less sophisticated than it is today). (Edited 90 --> 75.)
- code_duck 12y agoSo did those people get job training and move on to white collar jobs, or did their children? My guess is most of those farmers retired or died.
- ThomPete 12y agoThe transition went much much slower than it does today most people are missing a very important point here. We aren't just talking about automation of physical things we are also talking about automation of intelligence based tasks. Also people often bring out the horse carriages as an example of how the people who controlled those just went on to become car drivers instead but the horses they never found new occupation. Automation is replacing higher and higher levels of thinking and that is the problem. Its not just going to compete with you for your physical abilities but your mental ones. That's the big deal and thats where we are headed. Driverless cars illuminates that point quite substantially.
- nilkn 12y agoIt's much more likely that these drivers' children will move onto "intelligent work." The drivers themselves -- the ones for whom it's a primary source of income, anyway -- are mostly stuck in a financial rut. They don't exactly have the spare cash sitting around which would allow them to just learn some "creative work." Getting bills paid and food on the table for their family will take priority.
- sixQuarks 12y agoThings don't work like that in the real world. There is a very real problem when technology quickly makes an entire workforce obsolete. I believe there will eventually have to be a minimum income that is given to every adult. There will be many people choosing not to work who are fine living off this minimum income. There will also of course be those who would rather work but whose skills are obsolete.
- fatjokes 12y agoSomehow, I doubt Uber spends too much time worrying about morality.
- XorNot 12y agoI would've thought this is a business problem - it's developing a product which cannibalizes their own market. Uber's problem is that this is a big public announcement. And so what you have to be wondering is what all the Uber drivers are going to be thinking about their future today with Uber. There biggest problem in the next 5 years if they keep announcing self-driving car stuff could very well end up being that their competitors have an easy time poaching all their drivers.
- swombat 12y agoIt's not cannibalizing their market, it's exploding it. Currently, I will use uber infrequently because it's fairly cheap, half the price of a typical cab ride (and by contrast, I would say I use cabs rarely, when I have no other choice). If it becomes 1/10th the price of a typical cab ride, I would probably use it at every opportunity, all the time. More than 10x my current usage? Yes, probably.
- ThomPete 12y agothats great it just doesent help the drivers. They are not lacking rides they are lacking revenue from those rides.
- dougabug 12y agoThe flaw in this thesis is that Uber charges 25% of the fare, plus fees, while the driver takes on the cost of the vehicle (depreciation, maintenance, finance), gas, parking, and pretty much everything else. If you get rid of the drivers, then Uber has to pay for all of that. That would be vastly more expensive, riskier, and if passengers really did expect prices to drop 5x, operating margins would evaporate. Making 25% off of somebody else's capital and labor is a pretty good trick, I don't see Uber or anyone else getting a better deal than that.
- puranjay 12y agoTo be fair, Uber doesn't seem to promise any of its drivers a 'career'. It offers them a way to supplement their existing careers. I don't see how this is any different from factories replacing low skill labor with robots. As libertarian as it sounds, I would point the finger at drivers who think of driving as a 'career'.