3 ms·
>> Every now and then people (on HN and elsewhere) like to rediscover pilot-wave theory and other similar ideas that posit that billiard-ball-like-particles sti
by phkahler 12y ago
>> Every now and then people (on HN and elsewhere) like to rediscover pilot-wave theory and other similar ideas that posit that billiard-ball-like-particles still describe the universe.
Have you seen the experiments of Yves Couder?
Hypothetically, if a model like that produced an exact mathematical equivalent of quantum theory wouldn't that be more satisfying? It would also destroy some of the notions that have been mathematically proven - like EPR and Bells' inequality. A lot of people are unsatisfied with QM and looking for something more tangible - including physicists.
Apparently pilot wave theory was never soundly rejected, the crowd just went in a different direction.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- TTPrograms 12y agoYves Couder has demonstrated that you can construct a physical system that obeys the mathematics of pilot wave theory. This has zero bearing on if pilot wave theory is an accurate description of subatomic physics.
- danbruc 12y agoA lot of people are unsatisfied with QM and looking for something more tangible - including physicists. While I would also prefer that quantum mechanics turns out to be quite classical at its heart - with objective reality, locality and all that - it seems a pretty bad idea to expect or even assume that nature works the way we prefer it to and that it will be easily understandable for human brains. Actually, the longer we struggle to make sense of all of that, the more likely it seems to me that everything is actually radically different from the way we have looked at it for the past century.
- trhway 12y ago>Hypothetically, if a model like that produced an exact mathematical equivalent of quantum theory wouldn't that be more satisfying? It would also destroy some of the notions that have been mathematically proven - like EPR and Bells' inequality. destroying Bell's inequality would be the key. It would be very satisfying. I'd say Nobel prize and forever in history books satisfying. Unfortunately (as i myself is on the ERP side and came to a something like pivot wave on my own while trying to explain the double-slit) there is no reasonable explanation for observed Bell's violations except for the explanation by QM (which for a "realist" like me sounds just like "will of God spreading FTL" :) Note: actually i haven't been able to find good (for my criteria) Malus law verification for single photons - the law is the basis of Bell's violation claims in photon polarization experiments. Slight modification of the law on top of Einstein's proposed modification - with resulting law being pretty reasonable for single photon situation while still preserving classic law in the case of classic light ray - actually produces the Bell violation in the classic "local realism" explanation. So i still hope a bit :)
- lmm 12y agoBell's inequality is, as you say, mathematically proven - and experimentally verified. Destroying it is about as likely as finding out that 2+2=5. Pilot wave theory produces the same predictions (as do all interpretations of QM), so in some sense it's valid, but it's an ugly attempt to brush the fundamentals under the carpet; it makes some simple cases simpler, but it makes the really interesting QM harder. It's not wrong, in the same way that constructing Newton's laws in a rotating frame of reference is not wrong - but it's less pleasant to work with for most interesting problems, and obfuscates the physical reality.