7 ms·
> Mining the surface is required Why not get other resources from near-Venus asteroids and Mercury? It would be easy to imagine a near-sun economy that mostly
by stcredzero 12y ago
> Mining the surface is required
Why not get other resources from near-Venus asteroids and Mercury? It would be easy to imagine a near-sun economy that mostly involves people, information, and raw materials making the trip up and down the Venusian gravity well -- with most raw materials and finished goods making the trip down. Most of the energy would be dissipated by aerobraking. In essence, Venus could participate in such a solar-system spanning economy by supplying relatively friendly radiation-shielded Real Estate and fluorine. Raw materials would largely go down, and people, culture, intellectual property, and fluorine would come up.
- Terr_ 12y ago> Why not get other resources from near-Venus asteroids and Mercury? The exact same reason we don't get our resources from near-Earth asteroids and Earth's neighboring planets: It's freaking expensive. One of the aspects that makes Venus attractive for colonization--similar surface gravity--also makes it expensive to launch anything. More-so, given that you'd be doing it with a frontier outpost's industrial base. > Raw materials would largely go down, and people, culture, intellectual property, and fluorine would come up. So why bother going to Venus at all, as opposed to creating such an economy around Earth? Barring catastrophe, Earth will certainly have a lot more people, culture, intellectual property, value-dense high-tech goods, etc., as well as significantly nicer/cheaper real-estate. All successful colonies require an economic driver, and Venus is no exception. "Like Earth but less-profitable" is unlikely to do much.
- stcredzero 12y ago> The exact same reason we don't get our resources from near-Earth asteroids and Earth's neighboring planets: It's freaking expensive. Remember that I referenced its relative price. We don't get Earth's resources from near earth asteroids because we can get them more cheaply from Earth. Obviously, this wouldn't apply to Venus. Likewise, lots of things on the west coast of Alaska come from Seattle, not because it's cheap in absolute terms, but because it's the cheapest. > So why bother going to Venus at all, as opposed to creating such an economy around Earth? For the express purpose of not living on Earth. For the express purpose of spreading our civilization beyond the confines of one planet. Such an Earth independent economy and culture might be more likely to exist around Venus than Earth, simply because the proximity of Earth is more likely to pull investment away. > All successful colonies require an economic driver, and Venus is no exception. Not all colonies on Earth were motivated primarily by economics. People have lived in a variety of places on Earth motivated by religious and military concerns. Successful colonies will need economies to keep themselves going, but economic concerns are merely the strongest motivator for settlement, not the only ones. Granted they are in the minority, but there are people who live in the middle of deserts, in pressure vessels at the bottom of the ocean, in all kinds of remote wilderness, in many cases for the sake of living in such places as private citizens. Granted, it will be a long time before such civilizations would begin to remotely rival the scale of Earth's, but I'm sure they will come to exist and that they will achieve near self-sufficiency. Summary: People will live in space because they want to be there. Once a spacefaring population reaches a certain threshold, it will become self sufficient.
- userulluipeste 12y ago«"Like Earth but less-profitable" is unlikely to do much.» 1. Don't underestimate the human psychic. People are said to be rational, but we often come to surprise ourselves. As a joke, if you don't have sane/rational volunteers, just create a religion! 2. Don't overestimate the general conditions on our home planet. I hope I won't come to see it in my lifetime, but escaping from here could be similar (at least in sentiment) to escaping from one's home-town/home-country or worse. Things can always get worse in a lot of different ways, and then when comparing again, the Venus option could start to appear as a pragmatic one.
- mrec 12y agoI have a hard time imagining Earth getting so awful that Venus looks like the better option. Even after an all-out nuclear war, it wouldn't be that bad. This is what made the fundamental plot kicker of 'Interstellar' so daft. "Oh, we have a crop disease problem and dust storms? Clearly we must move the human race to another planet, even if it's a frozen hellscape with no breathable atmosphere." As opposed to, say, building some greenhouses, or ramping up aquaculture or aeroponics.
- starwaver 12y agoI absolutely agree with the plot flaws. I'm sure there are much easier ways to solve crop disease and dust storm problems. It'll probably involves alot of genetically modified crops and building dust proof houses.
- stcredzero 12y agoI have a hard time imagining Earth getting so awful that Venus looks like the better option. The moving to the new world involved taking on all sorts of new risks, but people still did it for non-economic reasons. Instead of religious freedom, perhaps others will be attracted by the prospect of starting new civilizations or escaping oppression?
- mrec 12y agoThey moved to the New World. They didn't move to the middle of Antarctica or the bottom of the Mariana Trench, both of which are far more hospitable than Venus.