7 ms·
Sell your poop for $13,000 per year
- username223 12y agoThe really crazy part is that once some pharmaceuticals push their own versions of fecal transplants through clinical trials, they'll try to raise the price patients pay for the treatment by 10x or so to make a profit. Of course... > Since they have to come into the Medford, Mass. office, lots of them are Tufts University students. And plenty are recruited from the gym next door. "It's great to have a healthy contingent of regular gym goers right there," Smith said. PoopDate.io has potential. DISRUPT that bathroom!
- giarc 12y agoThe problem with that is that it will push people back to DIY transplants. The same thing happened when the FDA changed the rules for FMT and the number of people doing it at home surged again. The FDA doesn't really know what to do about FMT and it's pushing people to complete at home transplants with untested donors and therefore putting themself at increase risk of adverse outcomes.
- username223 12y agoOh, I agree -- I don't know how to handle the problem either, and since the majority of our cells aren't human, there are plenty more microbiomes waiting to be transplanted (e.g. skin, underarms, feet). The incentives are incredibly perverse, with drug companies wanting to spend as little money as possible to develop drugs that appeal to the richest consumers, e.g. copycat drugs for old men who still want to get it up for their young mistresses.
- pervycreeper 12y agoNot what I thought it would be before clicking (too much internet for me, I suppose). One would imagine that testing would need to be fairly regular (no pun intended), so I'm not sure what the $5000 figure is meant to represent.
- stefantalpalaru 12y ago> poop It's a brave new world where vulgar and scientific words are replaced with baby talk.
- josefresco 12y agoThis is the Washington Post, not some scientific journal.
- stefantalpalaru 12y agoWhy should "feces" be used only in scientific journals?
- dignati 12y ago"fecal matter" is used later in the article. They probably just used "poop" in the title to catch more eyes.
- skierscott 12y agoAnd more clicks.
- DonHopkins 12y agoIt was a "Poop Culture" article.
- mattdotc 12y agoAstute observation. Much care is taken when writing headlines and in the case of news organizations with print editions in addition to their web presence, the web headline isn't necessarily the same as what runs in print because of different concerns, e.g. SEO vs journalistic standards.
- josefresco 12y agoI'm not saying they should - my point was that you shouldn't expect "scientific" terminology and language from the Washington Post.
- Expez 12y agoThis reminds of one of the greatest april fool jokes I've ever witnessed. In one of the papers there was an announcement by the parks department or some such about an effort to clean up the Vigeland park. The public was encouraged to pick up dog crap in the park and hand them in to attendants for a few bucks a pop. The turnout was great and the park was cleared of dog crap, but unfortunately no great fortunes were made :)
- kjs3 12y agoMy poop is worth every penny. Trust me.
- giarc 12y agoI actually donate on a regular basis (not part of OpenBiome) and can answer any questions people have (a sort of AMA). Edit - this isn't a joke comment, I actually donate stool weekly.
- zo1 12y agoI'm curious about the... Logistics of it? Do you store it, somewhere till the end of the week? Sit on a bucket, or use a ziplock bag? Scoop it out of the bowl every time? Do you have to make sure it doesn't get contaminated with urine? Do they care about the consistency, color, smell, etc? Or is it just pretty much anything goes? Do they request that you eat a specific diet?
- spyspy 12y agoFrom the article it seems the donors are required to go to the office and do their business there.
- giarc 12y agoIt would be nice to have a dedicated bathroom. I work in a large public building and therefore donate in a public bathroom. Can be awkward carrying a bag into the stall with me. I get some weird looks, but then I remember why I donate and it's all ok.
- giarc 12y agoFor me I work in the same building as the laboratory, therefore I use a collection container and deliver it "fresh" to the lab. I'm lucky because I'm fairly regular and donate around the same time everyday (9am) therefore I just walk down to the lab. A fellow donor is more of a night person, so they store it overnight in a container and bring it in the next day. The containers are just plastic containers (like a margarine container)m, single use. You place it in a trapezoid shape holder. Then place it on the toilet. If you place it one direction it collects stool, if you place it the other direction it collects urine. So yes, we do keep them separate. If I have a bout of diarrhea, I stop donating and wait for it to clear. I then collect samples and send to the lab for testing (ova and parasite, regular fecal culture, norovirus, hepatitis and some other viral testing). If I'm clear, I can continue to donate. This same process happens if I go on antibiotics or if I travel out of country. So anything goes, minus liquid stool. As for diet, I'm actually encouraged not to change my diet. My flora has shown to work well for recipients, and therefore if I change my diet I might change my flora.
- phkahler 12y agoWhy can't they just grow the desired types of bacteria? On a related note, how can the bacteria survive in "pro-biotic" pills that you can buy? I'm suspicious.
- gmarx 12y agoI was wondering that myself. One guess- the proportions are important and they don't know what culture medium to use. The gut is a complex environment. What if they grow it in a lab and some unknown minor microbe is selected out? On the other hand, I bet they're working on it.
- gww 12y agoNot every type of bacteria in your gut microbiome is known and/or able to be grown in culture. As per your question regarding pro-biotics, some bacteria such as Lactobacilli can be dried and remain viable when reintroduced to a liquid medium.
- abandonliberty 12y agoYes - we can only culture a very small minority of wild bacteria. For example, the recent antibiotic discovery that made the news came from learning how to culture soil bacteria. No, we didn't learn what it needs. We just grew it in it's natural environment: dirt. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8852487 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8852487 Revolutionary. (seriously).
- bduerst 12y agoAnaerobic bacteria are incredibly difficult to culture, especially if the specie is one that doesn't spore or last long in aerobic conditions. Those are most likely what are in the probiotic pills, but I do not know and am only speculating.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- ChuckMcM 12y agoThat is a crap load of cash :-) Interesting concept though.
- raisedbyninjas 12y agoFrom the donation benefits section: "Win competitions like biggest single donation of the month, or most donations in a month for bonuses and prizes!"
- Cyranix 12y agoA bit off-topic, but: for an incredibly over-the-top violent-but-funny animated movie whose plot revolves around profitable poo, give Aachi & Ssipak a try: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aachi_%26_Ssipak https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aachi_%26_Ssipak