5 ms·
I've always been surprised that NASA hasn't gone for a blimp type 'probe' for Venus. Something which floated above the clouds and allowed us to do long term obs
by ChuckMcM 12y ago
I've always been surprised that NASA hasn't gone for a blimp type 'probe' for Venus. Something which floated above the clouds and allowed us to do long term observation from that point.
We think in terms of "flying" through the atmosphere, but once it gets dense enough you can make the equivalent of fish to "swim" through it. With internal bouyancy compensation bladders, and a skin impervious to the atmosphere. Smaller probes swimming down into the clouds to collect data about the surface and other conditions.
If nothing else it would be completely different than exploring Mars :-)
- freehunter 12y ago>If nothing else it would be completely different than exploring Mars Which is likely why it hasn't been done. If it's something completely different, it takes more time and money to get it working. Starting from nothing, exploring Mars and exploring Venus might both cost $100b. But if the research has already been done to research Mars exploration, sending another probe there might only cost $2b, whereas Venus still costs $100b.
- ChuckMcM 12y agoNo doubt you are correct in that assessment. Time to fire up Kerbel to see how much payload a Falcon 9 Heavy can get into an Earth/Venus transfer orbit :-)
- throwaway_yy2Di 12y agoYou can actually look up the exact number for the current Falcon (non-heavy). It's ~1,900 kg (I think), for the minimum C3 of 8.5 km^2/s^2. https://books.google.com/books?id=vpilMLP7OHQC&pg=PA112 https://books.google.com/books?id=vpilMLP7OHQC&pg=PA112 http://www.spaceflightnow.com/falcon9/001/f9guide.pdf http://www.spaceflightnow.com/falcon9/001/f9guide.pdf (page 22)
- tachyonbeam 12y agoMy guess would be that NASA hasn't done this because they feel like they have the traditional "lander" or "descent" type of probe worked out. They've done the engineering, they know the difficulties involved. What you're suggesting requires more expensive R&D, and means that the new probe has more chance of failing. The conservative thing to do is to stick with what works. I do think you're right that the conditions are very different from Mars and this makes it possible to explore alternative approaches that may be better suited to the planet. I also believe that innovation entails some degree of risk taking. Just gotta get SpaceX onboard.
- pavel_lishin 12y agoI'm not sure that's the case; the latest Mars lander required some pretty incredible engineering - I mean, they basically built a rocket-powered hovercraft, something that's never been done before. I'd wager that the real reason is that Mars is more interesting to explore than Venus's atmosphere. Mars has the potential to have (or have had) life, and it has interesting geological features that may be directly applied to what we know about Earth. Plus, the whole "we might go live on Mars!" mentality doesn't hurt, and Venus is only recently getting this kind of attention.
- userulluipeste 12y ago"they basically built a rocket-powered hovercraft, something that's never been done before" They basically built a retro-rocket¹. Rockets existed, the principle of retro-rocket-like descent braking existed too (usually deployed on parachute drops of heavy equipment like tanks). "I'd wager that the real reason is that Mars is more interesting to explore than Venus's atmosphere." As you also noted, it's about public attention, which was fed with a lot of Mars stories. Mars' surface was more observable and thus made it more easily for Sci-Fiction writers to speculate about. It had less to do with practical considerations like those related to its atmosphere. ¹ http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Retrorocket http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Retrorocket
- rbanffy 12y agoNobody has the Venus lander thing figured out. Soviet landers could only last a short time before being roasted/crushed/corroded. In comparison to the Venusian surface, the religious notion of hell would be a tropical beach.