3 ms·
I don't think it's a good article at all. It refers to 'the bilingual advantage' like it's some atomic, indivisible thing. Even after spending a paragraph talki
by vacri 12y ago
I don't think it's a good article at all. It refers to 'the bilingual advantage' like it's some atomic, indivisible thing. Even after spending a paragraph talking about mixed results, it still refers to it atomically.
Such a binary worldview is harmful - for example, instead of totting up the number of pro-, neutral, and anti- conference abstracts, it would have been far more useful to look at what kind of abstracts showed benefits and not. It may have been that bilingual abstracts showed a benefit for certain auditory cognitive tasks, for example. Instead 'the bilingual advantage' is treated like a sporting team with a win/loss record, hardly appropriate for a complex cognitive concept.
Not to mention that totalling studies based only on the abstract is incredibly lazy. Abstracts are free of the minutae, and that minutae can be very important when two studies differ.