4 ms·
Adams wasn't criticizing science's updating of beliefs on new evidence. He was criticizing the practice of shouting "Hey! We're ultra-certain about this! Very
by SilasX 12y ago
Adams wasn't criticizing science's updating of beliefs on new evidence.
He was criticizing the practice of shouting "Hey! We're ultra-certain about this! Very important! You've got to do this!" when the truth was more like, "We kind of have some preliminary evidence this might be bad for you, stay tuned."
(And I don't buy the claim that it's just the media overblowing this; why weren't the national academies of science criticizing the food pyramid, at least in the sense of "okay it's not actually that important to eat 11 servings of bread a day".)
The point, then, is: don't be surprised when people are skeptical in those cases where you really are deservedly confident (e.g. vaccines).
If your evidence isn't very good and prone to being updated, that's fine! Just don't pretend to be confident it it.
- enraged_camel 12y ago>>He was criticizing the practice of shouting "Hey! We're ultra-certain about this! Very important! You've got to do this!" when the truth was more like, "We kind of have some preliminary evidence this might be bad for you, stay tuned." This is almost always a result of the "Science News Cycle." http://www.phdcomics.com/comics.php?n=1174 http://www.phdcomics.com/comics.php?n=1174 Aside from that, there's a lot of pressure on scientists to produce actionable results. People who fund science don't really understand it, and approach it with a mindset of, "I'm investing X dollars per year into this, and I should get Y dollars in return." So scientists either fake confidence in their findings, or fake their data to support their benefactor's cause.
- npsimons 12y agoAlso relevant: http://www.smbc-comics.com/index.php?db=comics&id=1623#comic http://www.smbc-comics.com/index.php?db=comics&id=1623#comic
- SilasX 12y agoIf it were just an issue of media hype, that would be a valid explanation for the food pyramid failure. But it's not just that. It's the fact that a) government experts believed it b) with high confidence that c) isn't justified, and d) are so confident that they plaster it in every classroom with all their authority behind it, and e) no scientific authorities go on record saying the real state of the research in case anyone bothers to get the real story. You can't blame the media for those parts.
- pdx 12y ago> those cases where you really are deservedly confident (e.g. vaccines) Why are you so confident in vaccines? There are papers saying your right to be confident http://1796kotok.com/pdfs/MMR_withdrawal.pdf http://1796kotok.com/pdfs/MMR_withdrawal.pdf ... and rebuttals to those papers. https://childhealthsafety.wordpress.com/2009/06/03/japvaxautism/ https://childhealthsafety.wordpress.com/2009/06/03/japvaxaut... Should we, as non-scientists automatically discount the rebuttals?
- FireBeyond 12y agoIf I look at the second website, I see "wing nut". That's not someone challenging us to be skeptical and seek out information. That's "All vaccines bad. Ever." "Autism, autism, autism." "Vaccines Did Not Save Us - 2 Centuries of Statistics" "Autism in Amish Children - 1:10000" - Hmm, this "study" doesn't really consider why the Amish community might be measured differently. I just see lots of links to studies that were either discredited, or original opining with little objective evidence. So, automatically? No. But some rebuttals are easier to discount than others - this is one.
- pdx 12y agoWell, yes, it's "Autism, autism, autism." That's why people are generally hesitant to vaccinate, and that's what the majority of the articles would be about. I confess that I had not noticed the "Vaccines Did Not Save Us - 2 Centuries of Statistics" article, and when you mentioned it, it did give me pause. However, I went back, found it, and read it. Did you? It sounded very "sciency", with lots of graphs and data. Is it correct in it's conclusions? Should be, if it's data is correct. Is it correct in it's data? I honestly have no idea. Is my gut instinct to discount it? Yes, absolutely it is. However, I certainly can't refute any of the data it's presenting me with, so why am I so quick to discount? I shouldn't be. You're either able to independently judge the veracity or lack of veracity of any given scientific claim, or you're not. If you're not, you need to remind yourself of that, and not be a voice in the mob. I need to remind myself of that too.