3 ms·
Based on incidence in Gecko, it is indeed most of them. It depends on your project, of course.
by pcwalton 12y ago
Based on incidence in Gecko, it is indeed most of them. It depends on your project, of course.
- tptacek 12y agoIt's a bit tautological to suggest that fixing the most common RCE flaws in C/C++ programs by replacing the language is the same as fixing all of the most common RCE flaws. The clear point here is that memory corruption is an affliction of C/C++ programs, but that other languages have other RCE-breeding flaws.
- MichaelGG 12y agoWhat are the other, common, RCEs? Command and SQL injection, upload and execute, etc. -- all those would apply to any language, right? Eval()/dynamic loading and little custom languages (like perhaps some "business rules" type systems) probably aren't as common in C/C++ eh? Same for overzealous serialization systems (like Ruby's YAML issues, and I think .NET's binary serialization)? What other kinds of things lead to RCE that don't or rarely occur in C/C++?
- tptacek 12y agoYou just hit a bunch of them. The C/C++ RCE bugs are buffer overflow (heap, stack, heap/stack via integers, &c), UAF (and double free), and uninitialized variables. It looks like there's a whole menagerie of different C/C++ RCE flaws, but they really just boil down to bounds checking, memory lifecycle, and initialization. Metacharacter bugs apply to all languages, but since Rust doesn't eliminate them --- virtually nothing does, with the possible exception of very rigorous type system programming in languages like Haskell --- the metacharacter bugs rebut the parent commenter's point. Eval() is an RCE unique to high-level dynamic languages. Taxonomically, you'd put serialization bugs here too (even the trickiest, like the Ruby Yaml thing, boil down to exposing an eval-like feature), along with the class of bugs best illustrated by PHP's RFI ("inject a reference to and sometimes upload a malicious library, then have it evaluated"). Those are just two bug metaclasses, but they describe a zillion different RCE bugs, and most of them are bugs that are not routinely discovered in C/C++ code.
- MichaelGG 12y agoIf you remove custom software like Intranet apps and focus more on products that have near ubiquitous deployment (like common desktop programs, OSes, basic server-level code), how do you think the come out? What about by number of people impacted?