4 ms·
> 99% of online advertisers give the rest a bad name So true; remove "online" from the sentence above and it's even truer. > it's why we hugely and desperatel
by bambax 12y ago
> 99% of online advertisers give the rest a bad name
So true; remove "online" from the sentence above and it's even truer.
> it's why we hugely and desperately and badly need to find another way of paying for content
Not sure about that.
Here are the ways I can think of we gain access to content:
- by directly paying for it (books, movies, etc.)
- by indirectly paying for it (ad supported newspapers articles and such)
- by paying for it via taxes (your proposal)
- because it's free.
The best content is undeniably that which people will specifically, directly buy with their own money[1].
And the second best is free.
All the other content distribution schemes produce bad content, either hollow or click-baity or just plain dumb.
My point is that AdBlock is saving the world.
1: For the purpose of this discussion, pirated is in the same category as paid-for.
- antihero 12y agoWhat would be interesting is a sort of all-content-subscription - you pay X per month, and it's divvied up between the providers/owners of whatever you use. Kind of like a tax, but actually related to usage. Would be very difficult to have the trust and integration required for it to work though.
- kuschku 12y agoSoooo, like Flattr?
- forgotpasswd3x 12y agoI had thought that would be an interesting way to set up a streaming music service. Ex: I'll agree to pay $X/month, and then at the end of the month, that money gets paid out to the artists I listened to based on how often I listened to them. It probably wouldn't work, but I don't really feel any current method of music sales is really working for most artists.
- dredmorbius 12y agoThat's pretty much my proposal, though with a few caveats. It's a flat fee. That is, you're paying the same whether you fetch a single work or 10,000. Aaron Swartz's mass document mining would be supported. If you're interested in large-scale literature analysis, it's possible. It's scaled to income / wealth. Information is part of what makes the system in which you're living possible. If the system's rewarded you, you reward the system back. Hence the tax element. Possibly scaling to some sort of connectivity plan might accomplish a similar aspect via price discrimination (of the old-school multi-tier service offering model, not the new-school hit-them-with-hidden-fees approach). There are tiers of compensation. Pumping out white noise / easy-to-generate content doesn't necessarily buy you high compensation. Detailed scientific / journalistic work does. Penalties for inaccuracy in genres where accuracy matters, especially against deliberate distortion. Implementation is the tricky bit.
- jerf 12y agoPatreon is saving the world, not AdBlock. It's still early but I expect in 10 years that "trying to make money via ads" is going to see "very 2010s", due to the lack of words for "something done from the late 1990s to the late 2010s". It just doesn't work. It almost works. It is so painfully close to working that we can taste it, which is why it has hung around so long. But eventually, advertising corrupts all souls. People respond to incentives, no matter how hard they try not to, and nobody sane should really try to build a quality content-production regime on people trying really hard to act as if the incentives they are operating under aren't the incentives they're operating under. Even when it "works" for some period of time I question the effects of such long-term self-deception.