5 ms·
This is really just an extension of the scotsman argument. For one, many people really do regularly relearn the benefits of arrays. To the point that maybe it
by taeric 12y ago
This is really just an extension of the scotsman argument.
For one, many people really do regularly relearn the benefits of arrays. To the point that maybe it should get more discussion.
For two, not everything can be a linguistic structure/syntax/grammar. Often they are pretty good highlevel descriptions of what is intended. Implementation left to the reader.
Which is ultimately the problem. Two implementations of the visitor pattern may have made different trade offs for what they are doing. Same for many other patterns. Singleton is often itself used as a tradeoff in terms of flexibility.
Now, I fully agree that when used without thinking/acknowledging the tradeoffs, they lead to issues. They are not unique here. Consider actors. Arguably the vogue pattern for the popular crowd nowdays. Can you honestly tell me the vanilla actor is a solid win?
- Retra 12y ago>not everything can be a linguistic structure/syntax/grammar. Says who? Why should I believe this?
- taeric 12y agoSays experience. Tritely, why should I believe the contrary? I've certainly seen it tried enough. Yet to work. There is also the parallel to spoken languages. Where there are pretty good patterns of speach for making different points. Why haven't all of those been converted to simply an atomic linguistic structure.
- Retra 12y agoExperience would have told you that human flight was impossible just 110 years ago. The reason you should believe the contrary is because it is an open world, and there is not proof that you are correct. >There is also the parallel to spoken languages. Where there are pretty good patterns of speach for making different points. And programming is largely a domain specific task today, so you could have pretty good patterns for it. But anyway, that parallel expresses a better point: language is extensible. If you have something in another spoken language to express, you can certainly do it in any other language. You just can't maximize terseness everywhere, which is not what we're using to measure how good a language is. The measure for this is terseness in proportion to usage, which doesn't conflict that rule. Especially if you can control terseness dynamically.
- taeric 12y agoAnd, for the longest time, banking on a miracle flying device would have been a terrible idea. Language is less extensible and more just plain mutable. Consider the phrase "firing rate" when applied to an archer. Something tells me this mutability is not a selling point around here.