3 ms·
There's a common but often-ignored meta-lesson here - begin by describing what the thing actually does, concretely. "An exploration in messaging innovation be
by pvg 17y ago
There's a common but often-ignored meta-lesson here - begin by describing what the thing actually does, concretely.
"An exploration in messaging innovation being led by the team responsible for Thunderbird, to explore new ways to use Open Web technologies to create useful, compelling messaging experiences" has near-zero information content and happily eats up the invaluable initial attention and visual spaces. One has to scale up a substantial wall of text before reaching anything specific but not before being invited on a detour into the 'Guiding Principles'. I didn't go down that path but presumably the principles include 'Be vague'.
It may sound like mere grouchy nit-picking but I've found that this type of failure at basic communication in a project's description is often indicative of its future lack of success. The pages of the Chandler project used to be a wonderfully instructive example but even they seem to have cleaned up their act on their current website. A very incomplete list of words and expressions to avoid before clearly stating what a product does -
revolutionary
innovation
vision
open
passionate
watch a video/screencast
Any others?
- hussong 17y agoCouldn't agree more. I'm looking at a number of payment processors and merchant services, and some make it extremely hard to figure out what they actually do--it's all buried in useless marketese.
- dstorrs 17y agoHear, hear! I read the first few sentences, saw "messaging"--strike one--saw a bunch of incoherent babble--strike two--then started skimming. Halfway down the page, I still had no idea what it actually DID, so I closed the page. Could someone who was more interested than I was sum this up in a sentence? What does it actually do?
- Adrenalist 17y agoI agree with your point. I had to do some digging to get more concrete information. When a friend’s link from YouTube or flickr arrives, your messaging client should be able to show the video or photos near or as part of the message, rather than rudely kicking you over to a separate browser tab. Notifications from computers and mailing lists should be organized for you, not clutter your Inbox or require tedious manual filter setup. It should be easy to smoothly integrate new web services into your conversation viewer entirely using open web technologies. http://labs.mozilla.com/raindrop/2009/10/22/introducing-raindrop/#post-1 http://labs.mozilla.com/raindrop/2009/10/22/introducing-rain...
- adamc 17y agoI read that far too, but it wasn't very compelling. Getting videos in my IM instead of clicking on a link is revolutionary? They may proove me wrong, but it didn't make me want to download it.