3 ms·
Why would anyone think that the value of a non-trivial asset could be expressed as a single number? Let's consider a house. Clearly the amount of money that s
by anamax 17y ago
Why would anyone think that the value of a non-trivial asset could be expressed as a single number?
Let's consider a house. Clearly the amount of money that someone would pay for said house varies from person to person. Which value is "correct"?
Before you jump in with some clever aggregation function, suppose that the owners want to sell said house. Will they agree to the value that your aggregation function produces? (They can choose to delay the sale, so if they don't agree, your function may well deprive someone of the ability to buy said house at a price that its acceptable to said someone.)
Ah, but you say that stock is stock. That's true, but again, different people have different priorities. I probably weight dividend paying history differently than you do. I have different expectations on inflation. I need to go liquid at different times. The end result is that we disagree about the value of the same share of Microsoft stock.
- crc32 17y agoThe single number does not have to be 100% accurate to be useful. The end result is that though we disagree about the value of the Microsoft stock, it nonetheless has been assigned a price by some invisible hand.
- cousin_it 17y agoLet's consider a house. Clearly the amount of money that someone would pay for said house varies from person to person. Which value is "correct"? The one that actually results in a deal happening, which often means the highest amount on offer. The more standardized a good is and the more it's traded, the more well-defined its price is. If deals don't happen, there's no market-clearing price, e.g. no way to price sex with Mother Theresa. Before you jump in with some clever aggregation function, suppose that the owners want to sell said house. Will they agree to the value that your aggregation function produces? Yes they will, by my definition above :-)
- anamax 17y agoThe market clearing price is one definition o "value", but the folks complaining about complexity of derivative pricing are clearly unwilling to accept it. BTW - Folks who don't participate in a deal often complain that the price at which it occurred was "wrong". Folks who can't find someone to buy from them at the price they want have an analogous complaint.