3 ms·
> Part of the confusion stems from the fact that the rental economy — taking its cue from the Internet in general — sees everything as either horrible or great,
by danso 12y ago
> Part of the confusion stems from the fact that the rental economy — taking its cue from the Internet in general — sees everything as either horrible or great, with little room for nuance. Lyft nods to this when it tells passengers reviewing drivers that “anything lower than 5 indicates that you were somehow unhappy with the ride.” Drivers can be dropped from their services when they fall below 4.5, but it is unclear what it takes to get banned as a passenger.
I've never used Lyft, but as an Uber customer, it seems like someone at Uber graduated from college and, either as a result of, or in a sly commentary on grade inflation, created an ambiguous rating system that encourages rating-inflation, while penalizing drivers based at the whims of what riders consider "4-star" to be.
4-stars on every other rating service, is pretty solid...yet if a driver averages 50/50 on both 4s and 5s, they are sanctioned (from what I've heard from drivers, the rating-cutoff can shift depending on the area and excess of drivers...in Silicon Valley, it might be higher than in other locales, for instance)...I've never given a driver less than 5-stars because I've never received awful service (though, certainly, I've had drivers who were late, or cars that were messy)...it's bad enough that they're scraping by, I don't need to pile on by giving them a slight demerit that could end their driving. But since the star-rating is basically a binary system, why not just make the question, "Were you satisfied with your ride?" and solicit the user for comments if the answer is the rare "No"...such a system would garner real feedback and improvement, at a very small price in the sensory satisfaction of clicking on a star (this might also prevent the problem of fat-fingered/drunk users accidentally giving a low rating).
- Chevalier 12y agoI agree completely. A binary yes/no would be a lot more useful in gauging customer satisfaction with drivers. When 5 stars is "yes" and 1-4 stars are "no," Uber forsakes the gradient system that, as far as I can tell, is the only merit of star rankings. That said... Amazon has likewise mutated star rankings. What was the statistic, that 80% of Amazon's products have a 4-5 star ranking? For any given listing, 5 stars indicates satisfaction, 4 stars indicates likely problems, and 3 stars indicates serious defects. I've never seen 1 or 2 star reviews except on long-tail products with less than a handful of reviews. Despite turning star rankings into blunt instruments, Amazon still features probably the most valuable, extensive reviews on the internet.
- ThrustVectoring 12y agoI definitely agree with the binary yes/no Also, instead of a percentage, list the good/bad ratio. 99% doesn't seem much different than 98%, but the first is 99 good experiences per bad one while the second is 49.
- malandrew 12y agoThe great part about the Amazon reviews is that for any product you can read some of the 4 and 5 star reviews and some of the 1 and 2 start reviews. Seeing why people were satisfied and why people were dissatisfied is very valuable in determining which start ratings reflect what you care about when purchasing a product.