3 ms·
As I read this story, Nokia appear to have a reasonable complaint in this case. It looks like they have spent significant resources building a brand around tha
by Silhouette 12y ago
As I read this story, Nokia appear to have a reasonable complaint in this case.
It looks like they have spent significant resources building a brand around that particular term in a closely related field, including registering trademarks. It then looks like a start-up has come along, not checked on the viability of its own proposed branding before adopting it, and run straight into basic laws about trademarks and passing off.
Maybe a real lawyer can tell us otherwise, but as far as I can see the fact that "here" is a widely used word in the English language doesn't seem to matter. After all, it's not as if you'd get far starting an on-line text editor and putting a big button labelled "Word" on the home page so you could write your first word.
Being a start-up doesn't entitle you not to follow the same laws as everyone else (notwithstanding the wishful thinking we sometimes see on certain Internet forums!) so if the report is accurate then it seems like Nokia do have reasonable grounds to object.
(Edit: Just to be clear, I'm not expressing any opinion on whether I think generic terms should be protected by the law, I'm only commenting on the situation as, to the best of my knowledge, it actually is today. Also, there are two distinct uses of the term "here" by the start-up mentioned in the article, one a prominent feature of one app and the second the name of a separate app, and I'm not arguing that these should or will necessarily be treated the same way. But launching an app with the same name as someone else's registered brand in a related field seems ill-advised.)
- KaiserPro 12y agoI think there is case law related to Hoover in the UK. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generic_trademark http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generic_trademark I heard a while back that Google were worried that if people started using the word Google as a verb for websearches it would make trademark/copyright difficult.
- jahewson 12y agoThat's the wrong example I'm afraid. Hoover is an example of a trademark which became generic because it wasn't enforced strongly enough. "Here" is already a descriptive word and while Nokia can use it for branding a product/service they can't make any claim over it's descriptive use.
- jahewson 12y agoThe fact that "here" is a widely used word does matter. What Nokia's trademark buys them is the right to name a product or business "here". It doesn't given them ownership of the word "here" when used with it's descriptive meaning, whether or not that use occurs in a similar product/business context. Given that the offending app allows people to notify others that they are "here", it's open to debate as to whether or not their use of the word is "merely descriptive". It's unlikely though. I agree that it probably would have been wise for the startup to avoid using that name, but they could well be within their rights to. Own the downside: should that be permitted, it guarantees that they won't be able to protect the name themselves either.
- Silhouette 12y agoThe fact that "here" is a widely used word does matter. What Nokia's trademark buys them is the right to name a product or business "here". It doesn't given them ownership of the word "here" when used with it's descriptive meaning, whether or not that use occurs in a similar product/business context. OK, but how is an app called Here merely using the word for its descriptive meaning? If you were only referring to the Here button in the other app made by the start-up, then I agree there seems to be some room for interpretation. Even then, though, if the fundamental justification for protecting trademarks and having related laws about "passing off" is to ensure that customers aren't duped into thinking they're dealing with someone else, an app that is named one thing but uses a related app's name so prominently in its UI seems to be at best a grey area.